jawab soalan ini

Nasihat Soalan

Should this teacher be fired...

An alumni of my high school who graduated last tahun committed suicide last Sunday, and it's been a very sensitive time for the last few days. I have a Jewish English teacher who's been teaching for decades and has tenure. Today in the class she had before mine, she berkata that the boy would not go to Heaven for what he did. This upset the whole class and they went to the guidance office, some in tears and others angry. The teacher was asked to leave and (though we don't know yet), was likely suspended.
In the Jewish (and some other) faiths, anyone who commits suicide goes to Hell. Freedom of speech gives her the right to speak her opinion. What also isn't being taken into account is the reasons behind why she berkata it, which we may never know.
My Facebook news feed is in the process of blowing up with posts about how disgusting, insensitive, and disgraceful her actions were. People don't want her to be allowed to return to school. Some are peaceful, but some are not. All are defending the honor of the deceased. Someone even started an Event to go to the administration and calmly address what happened. Someone wrote a message to the Department of Education and local news sites.
At first I was with everyone else 100%. After rethinking my papar on this, I found that I am not so sure. I can't really say that it was wrong for her to say that. I just think she shouldn't have berkata anything, and personal beliefs were wrongly mixed with work. The teacher has already gotten punished, and likely suspended. Because of all the talk surrounding the issue, and complaints from students, parents, and possibly other teachers, she may be reviewed sejak the school board. She has been accused of wrongful behavior before, and a lot of people hate her as a teacher in general. With this, she could likely be fired. She's 60 and would lose her job and retirement benefits. I don't think that she deserves that over this incident. People are upset and when they are upset, they also become a
*
ngry, and create lebih trouble that could be avoided if they left the issue in the hands of the administration. I just don't know what to think about it.
Crime-Drama-Bee posted hampir setahun yang lalu
 Crime-Drama-Bee posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Nasihat Jawapan

para-scence said:
I'd be offended too, and upset. But since it falls under "religion," I don't think she should be fired. That would be discrimination of religion; and like anda said, she has freedom of speech.

The students that were offended sejak it shouldn't worry about it, if it doesn't fall under their beliefs. For example, I don't worry about things that pertain to the Muslim religion, because I'm Christian; but I still respect their beliefs, and keep komen-komen to myself.

It's fine to be upsetted sejak this, but firing her isn't going to change what has been said.


select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
BabyBlud said:
^ i agree, i think this has been blown out of proportion.
Even though i don't agree with what this teacher has said, i can see her point. It was her opinion and papar on the way she was religiously brought up.

However, she could have berkata her opinion in a subtle way. Instead of saying this student is going to hell as he violated Jewish law, she could have educated her class on what the jewish beliefs were and then tell them, in my own opinion, i do believe he will go to hell, but i respect his family and Friends will think otherwise.
In all honesty, she should have kept that to herself, especially inside school and in front of her class.

I think, instead of firing her and making her lose her retirement benefits (which she clearly should recieve after giving lebih then 40 years worth of teaching and work), that she should have been temporarily suspended and made to take some sort of behavioural class to distinguish what can be berkata in the classroom and what can not pertaining certain subjects. Especially about a student.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
next question »