9 and 14, still not understanding the fairness of doing it in seperate picks, and why nowere there is a keep the current spot icon choice!

There are separate picks cause otherwise there were going to be 61 choces in one pick. I don't think it would be fair enough....

I agree with x-missmckena-x that there should be an option to keep the current spot icon... I like it a lot and I definitely think it is more suiting as a BtVS spot icon than all the icons in these 4 (I think it's 4?) picks.

there will be at the last pick where you have to choose by the 4 winners and the current one.

Why are you still planning on carrying on with the rounds thing when users keep saying they don't want our icon chosen that way? This is meant to be a choice we make as a spot, so if our spot members don't want to use rounds to choose then we need to use a different method. We're only going to end up having to do another pick anyway if you insist on choosing using a method people are unhappy with. Just do one pick or a countdown. At the very least do a pick asking if people would rather you used rounds or not. That way you are being fair and letting other users give equal input.

Rounds are an uneven way to do this. For example, the current icon has an unfair advantage over all the others since instead of putting it in one of your rounds you are automatically putting it the final.

The current icon Must be at the final pick!This isn't a contest.I'm not going to make another pick with all the icons except from the one that wins.At all the other spots when the icons are to many they make more picks so that is fair.If I had made one pick with all the icons then it wouldn't be fair i think.I'm the one thatr started the pick asking if the users wanted a new spot icon and I'm the one that made the forum so I think it is my job to do the pick as well.If you want I can make the final pick with the first 5 icons of each pick not only the first one ,but this is the only way.

Why must the current icon be in the final pick instead of fairly in the rounds like all the others? (well as fairly as rounds can be). Doing that gives it an unfair advantage.
I'm not asking you to make a new pick with all but the winner, I'm asking you to start from scratch and make either one pick with them all or a countdown with them all, like people have asked you to.
The icons are not too many for one pick. 61 will fit on one pick. Also, I have never seen a spot choose a new icon with rounds, but even if you have that doesn't matter. What matters is that in this spot our users have said they don't like using rounds. There is nothing unfair about doing just one pick because all one pick means each icon has equal levels of competition.

Being the one who started the forum doesn't give you more right to a say than everyone else! Enough people have said they dislike this method that you should listen. By ignoring people's input you are giving yourself more say than everyone else, and that's not fair, we all have equal right to say how our spot's decisions should be made. This is not the only way. Do one pick or a countdown. Or at least do a pick asking if people are ok with using rounds.

Here is an example of choosing the icon of a spot with many picks and not one!

link

link

I think it works just fine!!!

I'm voting just to see what's up here. I really like this one.

No offence but i dont think a character spot is a good example, this is a tv spot, they are alot differnt to making it for a character!