jawab soalan ini

Criminal Minds Soalan

ok why do anda hate ashley seaver??

ok.. so there been a lot of hate going around ashley character. and i have to wonder. do anda guys like genuinely not like her character atau just hate her because she replaced JJ??
dont get me wrong and i do really truly miss JJ and i wanna kill the freaking producers who fired her!!! but i mean like why hate ashley. so she replaced JJ but its not her fault.. it the producers and CBS. so i really dont see a reason to hate her.. i mean if example if Jj never left but ashley came into the picture would anda hate her?? i'm just saying but i just really want to know which is it.. like do u just genuinely dont like her character atau the fact that she was the replacement??
*
ok just commenting: saying that she replace JJ is not a reason, also i just hate does not count..
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
the reason i dont like JJ is that her father was a serial killer on the show. JJ berkata ''does the child of a sosiopath ever really have a chance?'' and the team don't know enough about her to trust her enough. How do we know that she could double menyeberang, cross the team!
matthewlover59 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Ashley not JJ
matthewlover59 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
 alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Criminal Minds Jawapan

Gleeky36 said:
I find it weird that AJ Cook had to be cut out of the tunjuk because of budget issues and then a new character appears that basically replaces her. That just doesn't make any sense to me...
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
i have been wondering that too.. but it assume it was because JJ was paid higher...
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
aww i dont know if i hate her cuz where i live i never seen episodes with her but I Cinta JJ shes like the nicest one
cre8tive2114 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
;D
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Kiniko90 said:
I dislike the fact that the producers replaced JJ with a poor imitation of our beloved Media Liason.

But I can't stand Seaver's character either. For one, she looks absolutely lifeless. Her eyes look dead, and she looks like she's bored all the time, and would rather be elsewhere. Apart from this, I really don't see the point of her character. Half the time that she's around, all every other character is doing is trying to explain some observation atau the other to her that she seems unable to understand. Then there's the fact that her backstory is absolutely pathetic. What the tunjuk generally does is reveal a character's past as the episodes go. But Seaver's is done. Gosh, her dad was a serial killer! Therefore, we must sympathize with her and make her, a mere FBI Cadet, a part of the BAU, disrespecting every other member of the team's effort to actually get where they are! And the fact that she was freaking highlighting her textbook with bleeding markers in one of the episodes! Jeez, I did that when I was 8th grade! Finally, they seem to be attempting to shove Reid/Seaver down our throats, but what the heck was with the way she dismissed his Doctor Who rant in Coda?

Well, sorry about my rant, but there's my opinion for you.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
miss jj. but like ashley too!
cassidy86 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Well, i have to say anda have a right to your opinion. but from what i understand of your answer anda are basically just unsatisfied with the fact that anda think she is a poor replacement for JJ. but think about it this way, she has only been in the tunjuk for like a few episodes, how are the writers suppose to fit in so many storylines into a 40min tunjuk especially when they are focusing on paget character and one of the episode on reid.. as for her observation skills, anda cant really say much because well first she hasn't exactly gotten a lot of screen time other than the first episode she was in but what is wrong with an explanations?? and anda never know, there may be lebih to seaver's past than we can see,s he has only been on air for a few epi so we cant really judge and say that. well on the seterusnya point, i never thought of it as a way of disrespect the other member and i dont think its disrespectful... i mean JJ isn't even a profiler for that matter and she was a part of the team but seaver isn't offically like a part of th team, and what is wrong w, she is lebih like on an internship atau something like that like a trainee. and also what is wrong with hi lighting?? i still hi light stuff?? and its useful... also lastly, i dont think they are trying to shove reid and seaver down our throats.
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
;D
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
allison152 said:
I really consider the Seaver character useless, but I don't hate her. I find annoying the people who hate Rachel Nichols because of Seaver. I mean, seriously, guys, it's not her fault her character kind of sucks. For me, there isn't really a reason why she's there, working with the most brilliant minds in the FBI. That's another thing that annoys me. She's there only because her dad was a serial killer. Rachel Nichols, on the other hand, seems to be a sweetheart. But it's gonna take me a long time until I'll get used to Seaver...
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
well maybe now she is a little bit useless but that's gonna change if she will get storyline that fits her....Well since anda all know that paget brewstar is leaving then might add another new character....So what anda will hate her too??? And it looks like everybody forgot that she replaced Lola Glaudini at season 2...
GoodF3lla posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
What anda didn't understand from my answer is that I don't hate Seaver. I just don't like that fact that she's not worthy of being at the BAU (a cadet?!) I don't even think she is there to replace JJ. God, NO! I don't like the fact that they're both blonde and have blue eyes, that I have to admit. What I don't understand is why AJ left in the first place, since Paget has been offered to stay and why make Rachel a regular instead of bringing AJ back, And no, I don't hate new characters just for the sake of it. I do only when they are badly written. Just like Seaver is.
allison152 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
:D
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
CriminalMinds12 said:
she was so mean to Reid in Coda and it looks like she doesn't give a crap that Prentiss Is gone
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
how was she mean??
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
LTboy said:
I don't hate her but I think a lot of what anda berkata might be true for some people - they are upset about the aj/paget cuts and resent Ashley for being there instead. Plus it doesn't seem like she's a full-fledged member of the team yet like isn't she a trainee atau an FBI cadet? So her character on the tunjuk isn't that mature atau evolved yet and maybe that is evident and makes her seem blah so that makes what people feel about her and the situation even worse. I am also shocked and pissed about AJs and paget's cuts.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
well, she isn't full pledge member yet but she is an official member of the cast as of a few episodes ago.. that is true taht her character isn't mature and for taht fact we know little a about which is another point which we should not hate.. her we know nothing about her.. and i am too am shocked about the cuts.. what u say could be true. thank anda ;D i really gonna miss padget a lot.. any idea if there is gonna be a replacement for her?? lols
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
I don't know if there's gonna be a relacement for Paget, but if there were I can see people hating her even lebih than Ashley cuz Emily was even lebih popular than JJ. I think if ashleys character was lebih exciting people would like her lebih but like I berkata she is kind of blah. People have emotional reactions to their kegemaran characters leaving and being 'replaced' i for one blame the producers and will stop watching cm after 6x18 Paget's last epi cuz she was my fave.
LTboy posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
yeah.. i know.. i have accepted taht fact.. and have already found a link.. guess i was just in denial
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
hottiecoolcat said:
cuz shes tryimg to b JJ and she replaced JJ so i hate her
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
yeah but with all due respect taht not really a reason.. she did not choose to be JJ replacement.. the producers are the ones who put her in.. and how is she trying to be JJ???
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
OMG!! i did not know that.. spoiler slert much?? nvm. i'm so sorry then. i really did not know that, mayb taht explains why so many ppl hate ppl rather ship JJ and reid.. (stating obvious) sorry. thanks for the insight
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
welcome
hottiecoolcat posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Lackson4ever85 said:
i really like her:D,but i can see why others not like her so much,because is was wrong that JJ leave
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
u what
hottiecoolcat posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
i have non reason to not like her really
Lackson4ever85 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
what does the actress do in real life have to do with her character??
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
ErHead07 said:
I don't hate Seaver atau the actress who plays her, Rachel Nichols. At the beginning, I didn't WANT to like her, but her first ep. I thought was really great both character-wise and acting-wise from Rachel. I don't think her character has been very well utilized since that first ep., but I'm gibing her a chance because Rachel Nichols reallly is sweet. It wasn't her fault A.J. left; she had nothing to do with it. :)
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
that it true.. maybe once this whole paget thing is over they will give her an actual storyline. thanks for answering.
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
I think so..... I honestly hope the Paget thing WON'T be over... I hope she comes back! CM will be so different without her... Itll just look like someone's missing.. :/
ErHead07 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
YES!! i know!!
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Agreed :)
Kaydie posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Roseflower35 said:
Well...I hate Her!!!!!!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
ok.........thanks for answering ;D
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
......the Reason why I hate that jalang, perempuan jalang is cuz she thinks shes all that!!!!!!! and she might Even WIN Reid's heart! I mean what if they get 2gether!!!!!!!???? Hell No!!!!!!!
Roseflower35 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
thanks for the komen ;D
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
GoodF3lla said:
well actually aj wasn't fired just that time they cut wages and they had to replace her with someone cheaper let's say but aj has oportunity to comeback...What about Ashley i do like her but i want to know lebih about her character...
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
agreed! so far i think her character is pretty interesting.. i cant wait to find out more. thanks for the insight about AJ i was just guessing honestly had no idea.
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
HouseAddict87 said:
I wouldn't really say I hate the character but I do strongly dislike her. For two reasons one being the obvious for replacing JJ in a way and then I just find the character pointless and boring. Nothing against Rachel Nichols I like her as an actress and just feel bad that she got the oppurtunity to act on a great tunjuk at a bad time. They should have waited to bring on a new character until the whole JJ/Prentiss mess was cleared up and peminat-peminat had cooled off at being upset. I think the character would have been better welcomed and accepted if two of the shows dearly loved characters weren't axed the same season she was brought on.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
u may have a good point that she was being introduced at the wrong time. but dont anda think if she wasn't the tunjuk would seem very sexist wither way it sort of is. i mean u only have emily out in the field garcia does not count as she is mostly in her room. but i dont see how her character is pointless and boring. i mena i sorta do but we barely know her. and replacing JJ is not really a valid reason. thats was why i asked this qn in the first place. i'm confuse how anda guys could so quickly judge seaver so quickly. i mean she barely has any lines in the episode. i get that like if she has not lines and purpose why on earth did she have to replace JJ but i honestly think there is lebih to ashley.
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
@Kiniko90 I totally 100% agree with you! Every word! and Rachel Nichols is an extremely bad actress. she should stick with modeling!
pearlygirl posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
ok i have no idea who your agreeing to but i mean fine if u think she a bad actress then fine but why are u commenting it here?? this qn is about ur opinion of the character..
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Celina79 said:
I don't hate her at all! It's not her fault, that JJ had to leave. We should be upset about CBS, and what they did to AJ and Paget.
Well Seaver's character couldn't shine till now, I hope the writers will write some better scripts for her.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
R U OUT OF UR MIND????WAIT LET ME ANSWER FOR YES
hottiecoolcat posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
i agreed to totally with celina! thanks anda for answering.
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Aline1102 said:
I think she's too young and doesn't have the experience to sertai the B.A.U, which is an elite team in the F.B.I. Have anda ever seen an elite team hiring someone under 30? Of course, there's Reid, but Ashley is far from having a 187 IQ!
Then, I think she replaced J.J. in a bad time. If she had come at the end of the fifth season, while both J.J. and Emily were still there, maybe the peminat-peminat would have accepted her. Like some other fans, I don't see the point of firing A.J. and Paget for financial reason just to hire this girl after that. It doesn't make sense to me.
And finally, Ashlet seems to be totally "out" of the team: she looks like as she, gerself, didn't know what she's doing there. She doesn't quite match with the other members of the team, with the spirit that exists in the team (maybe, again, because of her lack of experience?).
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
ok. so she does not have the experience, but we know from reid that exprience is just one part of the entire thing, well ok reid id a brainiac but ashley has like a different perspective to things.so even if she does not have a genius IQ she still is contributing something to a the team. it not teh matter oif how smart the person is, its what the person can offer to the team. i agree about the part taht she replace JJ at a bad time and i dun get why she got hired.. made no sense. and lastly she does sometimes feel a little out od place espically in the first episode she was in but i think it has gotten a lot better. she does participate in dicussion. and nowadays somtimes lebih than reid. it like the writers have shorten reid lines probably cause some episodes, Matt directs them. but is it possible anda feel she is out of place because anda are still not reall used to her yet??
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Yes, maybe I'm not used to her. But I don't hate her, I think sh'e got an interesting story (her father being a serial killer) that could be useful in further episodes centered on her. And I agree with anda that the brain isn't everything, but anda can't denie she lacks the field experience (her first mission with the team nearly turned into a catastrophe, she could have got killed). And I don't know if she's strong enough for the job, she doesn't look tough enough for the B.A.U. I hope I'll get used to her, if she stays... ;-)
Aline1102 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
ladycountry said:
I don't hate Ashley.At 1st i hated her cuz she replaced JJ but then i started likeing her.I really miss JJ & i hope that Ashley will be on criminal minds 4 some lebih episodes now that JJ's back.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
Brooke123456 said:
I HATE her. I have some idea for plot lines: Seaver drowns, Seaver gets shot, Seaver goes missing and no one bothers to look.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
Chaann94 said:
This is gonna be weird, but...
JJ has always been my fav character. And normally, I always would hate any replacement atau any character who is new in the show. But I've never hated Rossi and Ashley for a moment. I actually like them a lot!
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
awesome!
alisonfaith297 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
that's understandable i think
GoodF3lla posted hampir setahun yang lalu
BeantownBoriqua said:
I don't hate atau like her. My opinion is still up in the air with Ashley. I'm always willing to give new characters chances but there are times when I wonder why she is even there. I think they need to write her better. Mind anda I am a huge JJ peminat & was mad that she left but that is not Ashley's fault. I also agree with people who say she was brought in at the wrong time.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
CriminalMinds39 said:
Cause shes a fag.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
IllyriaSaxon said:
I actually don't mind Seaver- the character that is. It's the actress I can't stand. She's not very diverse and she has no personality- especially so in this show. Does she really have to go around with her eyes half-open all the time? Is the character high? atau dead?

On a side-note, I Cinta JJ- I didn't at first (always loved the actress regardless) but she grew on me.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
If Seaver was an in-again-out-again character I could probably get over it...
IllyriaSaxon posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Summonearth said:
I find it kind of refreshing to have a new character on the show. I really like Emily and JJ and all, but I also want to see some new characters on the team.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
AJJJ said:
I think it's because she replaced AJ when no real CM peminat-peminat wanted her gone and because of the whole sob story "my daddy killed people and now Im a strong FBI agent who likes to disobey." I just didnt like her in general but the fact she looked so much like "JJ" and replaced AJ were just extra.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
MadamAlbs said:
Okay so I'm a little late to the party but I'm only catching up on criminal minds now after forgiving the tunjuk for the absence of Mandy Pantinkin (please don't comment, just saying I Cinta Mandy, loved Jason, and found it difficult to get used to the tunjuk without him when the change first happened - it just had a different groove I couldn't get used to at the time) but I fail to understand the hate of Ashley Seaver to this hari and find it a real shame that the character was Lost due to unnecessary hate. Yes the firing of AJ and Paget was rather... disgusting for lack of a better term, it made CM look like an old Boys club but Ashley had a new dynamic not seen before and could have taken CM in a different direction plot wise. She was inexperienced and that would have allowed for new mistakes and new interesting plots, but now if seems as though CM has gone in the direction of giving peminat-peminat lebih of the same. Of course, if the peminat-peminat are happy with lebih of the same that's only logical, it is just still a real shame,

I for one do not agree with hating a character just because they could actually be a prospective Cinta interest for another popular character on the show. It's hard enough for women to get truly empowering roles on Televisyen without being forced out of it because peminat-peminat are protective of their on screen boyfriends. I was a little freaked out sejak the visual similarities between AJ and Rachel, don't think that was a smart idea, but that's not something Rachel could have really helped - she was born that way guys (as she is naturally blonde and blue-eyed), CBS hired her! I'm reaching the end of season six now and I genuinely don't think the character had enough time to flourish before being written off as 'boring'. Even Emily took me some time to like and deem as interesting and that wasn't poor writing, that was down to the set up of the show. CM episodes usually are standalone stories, they have a beginning, middle and end within one episode, sometimes two. In those standalone stories we learn tidbits of the characters lives but we don't really feel anything for them because it's all stuff that's happened in the past.

The idea of a several episode story arc wasn't REALLY introduced until Aaron's escapades with the Boston Reaper and honestly, I'm surprised it took that long for the writers to realise we need that sort of thing to become lebih interested and invested in their characters. Ashley Seaver, from what I can see, never got to her several episode story arc and therefore never had a chance. She was written off before she truly began.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
QwertyOrPen said:
I don't hate her per se, but I dislike the way her character was written. She came across in Season 7 as a bit of a Mary-Sue. They were in a rush to add her to the team to replace JJ.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
mrs_graygubler said:
I have no idea why I hate her, I just do I guess.. It doesn't help that she replaced JJ but the way she jumps into things and always makes things about her.. Also, I think being a relative of a serial killer, it makes her lebih emotionally attached to cases which could interfere with how she works a case.. She also didnt have much personality to her character as the others do, she's just a trainee
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
Goldguyt said:
I think JJ is sejak far the best, but Ashley is a perfect replacement. I was skeptical initially because I was ticked off at the people who fired JJ. BUT after a few episodes I realized she was doing a great job. She seemed to fit in, she's a really good actress and she is beautiful! What lebih could anda want if anda can't have JJ back?
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
Skelvin said:
To be entirely honest, Ashley Seaver felt like the writers pulled a character out of some cringy fanfiction on the internet. The tragic backstory is way too cliche and was scripted in what felt like a very overdramatic, unrealistic way, and the character in general was just too perfect - she came off as very unrealistic to me. The circumstances of her ending up on the team seemed forced, and she never meshed well with the rest of the team, just disrupted the interaction dynamics.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
hannahdyson10 said:
I am not keen on Ashley Weaver.
Not just because she replaced JJ, but also because she seems way too confident and self righteous, she put both herself and her team in jeopardy on her first case. She forbade Hotch on her FIRST case. And also she has no personality. The only thing remotely interesting about her is that her dad is a serial killer.
Disregarding all of that, she judges everyone so easily on the team, doesn't add anything to the team that it doesn't already have, and puts the team off balance.
The fact that I like JJ has not swayed my opinion of seaver. She just isn't a good character in my opinion x
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
next question »