do anda think that it was fare for edward to leave bella in new moon

OMG! i almost cried when he did that to her... I Cinta EDWARD CULLEN SO MUCH!! HE IS THE BEST!!

i was sad when he left but he wanted to protect her:) but because he done that she got closer to jacob:(..

NOOO!!!!!! HES SUCH A MORON FOR THAT

Yes....like Evka :)said he was trying to protect her..and in New Moon I am tottaly on his side!:)...

No!!!!!!! i wanted to kick his but 4 that

This is a tough one because I Cinta Edward but I still think he shouldn't have left bella .... However he thourght that leaving would make her safe, so he was just trying to protect her. Also if he had not left then edward would'nt have realised just how much bella needs him and loves him. so i kinda think it was fair of him because he had no idea how much she needed him - he was just trying to protect her - anda can't really ask for lebih than a guy who will do anything to protect anda - right ?

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!

it was sad but he only did it 2 protect her :)♥

Yes and no.
Yes, because he wanted to protect her, but not luring trouble to her, I guess. And no, because Bella needed him and she wouldn't be able to go on if he left.
But he came back, (or Bella went to him, whatever) and that's the main thing.
-xo.

no i was crying when that happened and when he tried to kill himself i was sobbing

Lets focus on the fact that they're together now!

No!!!! he hart her so bad and he didn't seem hart at all until he thought she was dead!!

i cried alot & then when the seterusnya 20 ch were about jake i was ok, but when edward & bella reunited i cried 10% lebih than when he left!!!!!

Yes & No. He needed to make her selamat, peti deposit keselamatan again and leaving was the best way. But it hurt her. They fell in Cinta she cant just forget about him.

if anda read on anda will see that edward only did it to protect her.

It wasn't only hard for Bella. Sure, she almost died because edward left her, but he made that for Bella. Edward thought that he is not god for them, and I thing that is so strong from Edward. I mean, Bella is the Cinta of his life, and he just want that she has a good life. Edward almost died too, when he could.

Sorry for my english i'm not really good, but i hope anda can understand it.

Yes. I would like New Moon if he was in it but it wouldn't make much since then. I think it was fair but also I wish it wasn't!

i read new moon before the movie and i was crying so hard wen i read that part but it does add adrenaline to the book and movie