Harry Potter Club
sertai
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
posted by bendaimmortal
I think there's something fishy to it. Because it's horribly unreliable and through that horribly unfair and useless.

Some theorize that magical children are born with the Trace but I don't think so because the buku talk about it as something that is put on people, as in a charm. And in magic it should be possible to make a lebih specifically effective charm. Even the Magic Quill at Hogwarts lists the names of every magical inhdividual born. The Trace should be working the samw way but it isn't.

I've racked my brain with the Trace matters after I (in the jawapan part of thsi club) brought up the soalan whether it remains active until the 17th birthday even if a minor drops out of Hogwarts years before he/she turns 17. (Because the Trace seems to be placed only on verified Hogwarts students to begin with (as Hermione received nno warnings though she studied spells before she began Hogwarts) and expulsion seems to be the worst thing they'll do if taking action seems needed. As in the Trace seems to very strongly relate to literally studying at Hogwarts, so I wondered if they'd remove it when a person chooses to drop out.)

But then I figured it really doesn't make much of a difference if it is atau isn't, because 95% of minors can get away with magic even with the Trace on. To some extent, everyone can.

Because if I've understood corerectly...To the Ministry of Magic, the Trace can only detect:
1. that magic has been performed nearby an underage wizard atau a witch
2. which charm/spell/curse was used
3. the location

But it does not detect who the underage wizard was. They can only try to figure it out sejak the location.

This leads into it being completely impossible for the MoM to blame a minor living with one atau lebih magical adults, and thus (supposing the parents are not around atau just dont' care) for the minor to perform any amount of magic at their own house without any consequences. But minors living with muggle adults are totally opposite case.

And a minor could walk into the area of berkata kind of minor and perform magic there, and this innocent minor would get the blame! (Much like what happened with Dobby the house-elf and Harry.)

And a minor could throw charms, even in the presence of a muggle, in any location that has numerous underage wizards living there, and then just flee from the crime scene before someone from the Ministry gets there to try and identify who it was. The Ministry would have hard time finding out who of the numerous minors living on the area, is guilty, if any as it mightr as well have been an adult in the company of a minor. And even if it was the unknown minor around whom the magic happened, they could've used someone else's wand and thus if the Ministry actually took time to go through all the houses with a minor living in, they'd never find out who it was atau might end up accusing the wrong person.

And seeing to the fact that totally muggle-free areas are rare, it is likely there usually do live lebih than one underage wizard atau a witch on one muggle-habited area. Which again deeply affects the chances of the finger being pointed at the right minor, if the magic happened outdoors.

They obviously rely much on the parents enforcing the rules on their children for the sake of the secrecy and the child's safety. But if the Ministry really wanted to give their two cents to the cuase...Why did they make the Trace so gawddamn vague instead of making it detect the sourcerer's indetity? That way the effect would be maximum and it would be catching equally everyone. The way the Trace is, doesn't offer any real help whatsoever but on the contrary it picks on those and only those children with less pure blood and/or not so fortunate utama location. And even if it did offer a little help, it's minus aspects are far lebih numerous/significant.

Thus, to me it seems that with the Trace, the Ministry does not have the childrens' best interest in mind, nor do they care about the secrecy that much.

It seems to have a touch of attitude problem towards muggle-borns and favorism of purebloods and half-bloods. And also of a lust for power, (hence the 'we can accuse, warn and punish children based on our vague assumptions, and anda have to live with it because there's no hihgher law to our society than us. Har-har-har!')

The law forbidding underage sourcery in presence of a muggle is of course all good and well and certainly out of right and respectable motives. But "the Trace" that supposedly enforces that law, really seems to be ill-motived and completely useless to far extent.

Do anda think I'm on to something here, atau that this is just Rowling's failure to pull together one aspect of her fictional world - atau am I missing something crucial?
added by abbott_hannah
To my fellow Gryffindor's

Hey! So even though Gryffindor was a very popular house in the Filem and books, in real life most of the people aren't in Gryffindor. I don't know why that counts cool, but they wanna be "different" atau choose Draco's side, Slytherin because they have a crush on him atau somehow obsessed with him ( trust me, all the teenage girls I met are,)

As a Gryffindor, I sometimes feel very left out. anda can always find a Ravenclaw, Slytherin atau Hufflepuff out there but only the 1 percent is Gryffindor. However, I learned to be proud of my house. I really am. If you're in Gryffindor,...
continue reading...
 Bellatrix is so gorgeous, but Voldemort is so ugly :/
Bellatrix is so gorgeous, but Voldemort is so ugly :/
Hey! I'm back to Penulisan after a small break. This time, I'm focusing on fandom shipping.

So the half of the artikel-artikel that I wrote in this club are about shipping. I ship Hermione and Harry, like Hermione and Ron a bit, and find Ginny bad about relationships. I also remember I wrote about Albus X Minerva, and I berkata they won't work out. Okay, if anda have noticed this is all about the hero shipping. What about the villains? They can have a Cinta life too. If anda know me, anda know I mostly hate villains. But people ship Bella and Voldemort together so much, that I had to share my opinion on it....
continue reading...
posted by elsafan1010
Weasley's are a very big family that take part in the movie, so I decided to write their family down. Enjoy <3

Arthur Weasley is the father in the family. He likes muggles and muggle stuff. Works in the Ministry of Magic, Misuse of Muggle Artefacts Office.

Molly Weasley is Arthur's wife, the mom in the family. Loves helping people, looks and cares after her children and sometimes struggles because they aren't financially in a good situation. Treats Harry so good.

Bill Weasley is the oldest child of the couple, graduated Hogwarts. After this, he went to Egypt and worked for Gringotts as a curse-breaker...
continue reading...
posted by elsafan1010
TOTAL LIST
1- Ask her if she's poor enough to afford a normal pen rather than the banned ones.

2- Call her Pinkie Pie.

3- Tell her you're gonna give her a dress for birthday and when she asks put a dress on a toad and tunjuk her.

4- Tell her Lockhart did a better job teaching than her.

5- Don't say anything when she punishes anda and when she tells anda "Why don't anda speak up" tell her that anda can't talk bad with animals.

6- Call Madam Pomfrey every saat she speaks and say "You don't sound good, miss,"

7- Tell her that she should have been in the Hogwarts House called Pinkies.

8- Turn her into a toad...
continue reading...
There is a popular theory among non-Harry/Ginny-fans that Harry only fell for Ginny as a result of her giving him a Cinta potion. They claim that Harry's feelings developed too suddenly to be natural and that Ginny was obsessed and desperate enough to do this in order to win Harry. They also claim that the prevalence of Cinta potions and potions in general within Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince hints that a Cinta potion was used. The theory is particular popular among film-only fans.

The first problem with this theory is that Harry's behaviour doesn't match that of the only other example...
continue reading...
1. Some lebih minor characters, such as Dobby, were only included in the films where their roles were pivotal. Others such as Peeves were excluded entirely. The development of minor relationships such as Tonks/Lupin and Bill/Fleur was cut.

2. The locations for Harry/Ginny and Ron/Hermione's first kisses were both altered in the films. Some smaller scenes between the couples were also changed atau added in. Scenes such as Harry and Hermione dancing in Deathly Hallows were added to please their peminat-peminat and to create lebih of an impression of a Cinta triangle.

3. Some characters' appearances didn't fully...
continue reading...
added by DarkSarcasm
Source: Chamber of Shitposts
added by Dundee673
added by Dundee673
added by 0YouCanFly0
added by Hermione4evr
Source: hermione4evr
video
Harry Potter
romantic
moments
bahagian, atas 10
watchmojouk
added by saanvijaiswal
added by Hermione4evr
added by LeviTheAckerman
added by Hermione4evr