jawab soalan ini

Lord of the Rings Soalan

Because J.R.R Tolkien was Christian, do anda think the Lord of the Rings is sort of an analogy to Christian beliefs?

In the movie, Gandalf sacrificed himself like Christ did. He resurrected as well. Additionally, the Ring could be Sin and Frodo's whole journey could be his whole life adventure on its way to get rid of Sin aka Ring and stuff. The elves are the Bidadari and the Eye is Satan. I've been pondering it for a while. The Orcs are the demons. Smeagol is a temptation and all the catostrophes and challenges Frodo encounters are temptation, and other evils. Etc, anda get the point. Most people don't acknowledge this, but I've been thinking. Tell me your thoughts on it. I'm just wondering and I hope this isn't spam. I think it's pretty related to the movies.
 icuSTALKER posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Lord of the Rings Jawapan

Arador said:
Many Christian themes are present in the Lord of the Rings, but Tolkien went out of his way to avoid using direct analogies. In fact, he disapproved of the way C.S Lewis (who was a good friend of his) incorporated Kristian directly into his work, believing that it ruined the story. He made sure of making this clear, saying in the foreword to The Fellowhip of the Ring:
"As for any inner meaning atau 'message', it has in the intention of the penulis none. It is neither allegorical atau topical... But I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations, and always have done so since I grew old and wary enough to detect its presence. I much prefer history, true atau feigned, with its varied applicability to the thought and experience of readers."
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
nglenn9 said:
Yeah, I think so. like c.s lewis and Narnia Chronicle's.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
J.R.R. Tolkien was Friends with C.S. Lewis... xD not even related to the question, but just a Rawak fact to enjoy >.>
kiss_me508 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Lolz yes that was true. I have reason to believe C.S. Lewis also used Kristian as an analogy. I know Tolkien disapproved of the fact that C.S. Lewis wrote children's buku but was a Christian. That's all I know. So I was just wondering what anda guys thought of him if he HAD used Kristian in his writing. There's nothing wrong with it and it doesn't ruin the story. But it's kinda cool if he did use the analogy that he expressed his faith in such a unique way. That's all I'm saying. I believe that yes, he did. There's too many similarities in the movie for me to believe no, and this is reinforced because of my childhood in the church. And the fact that he was Christian only enforces this thought of mine. I've watched The Lord of the Rings since I was three and I've always noticed it. Thanks guys!!!:D:D:D
icuSTALKER posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
ur welcme:)
nglenn9 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
yep..very true, kiss_me508! ^
nglenn9 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
blackpanther666 said:
I don't think he had it mind when he wrote Lord of the Rings... There is no evidence that he was ever Christian and it seems like a bit of stretch to think of God and Christian beliefs while Penulisan a large trilogy like LOTR. Plus, he also wrote a lot of other great buku as well, which have no evidence of anything to do with Christianity.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
"There was no evidence that he was ever a Christian"?? Do your research before anda make statements like that, and anda will find out that he was a devout catholic. In fact, he helped to convert his friend C.S Lewis, who was previously an atheist.
Arador posted hampir setahun yang lalu
ImAnEasel said:
I hope not - it would ruin the originality of Lord of The Rings. I've always thought of it as really imaginative, but, if your theory is correct, it would just be the bible slightly changed, with different names and creatures...

So, I'm going to think optimistically, here. My answer: No.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
i don't really think so either, though it does share some similarities.
kiss_me508 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
delamico said:
No, I don't think The Lord of the Rings is a metaphoric analogy to Christian beliefs. They may have provided some basis to the morals and spirits of the story, but The Lord of the Rings is also based on ancient Northern and German stories, the sagas.
Besides, the Lord of the Rings Fantasi world does not include a religious culture. We don't know anything about the religions of the folk of Middle-Earth, there are no temples, no sacred places, priests and nuns. It is not even revealed how King Elessar wedded Arwen (you'd assume there was a white dress, a great church, a priest to wed them and whatever weddings come with).
I don't think anda need to take the Ring as metaphor for Sin atau Sauron as that of Satan to find how religious Tolkien was. All of the characters are cold blooded to the extreme and very moral, they aren't glutton atau lusty, sometimes anda assume they have water in their veins. No graphic violence, no hedonism, no selfishness and above all no sex whatsoever. The good characters are as white as the bedsheets of a maid and the bad characters are as black as coal. The Lord of the Rings is an epic story, but sometimes anda wish the characters acted as though they were alive. For those two things, lust and greed, alih the world since the first ikan came ashore, atau lebih befit to the question, since God created the first ikan and told them to populate the world.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
JFlanagan said:
well i think about that al well i mean if anda think about it it could be related to Kristian and the Bible and i know tolkien was a christian but i don'n totally think it was based atau meant to be like the Bible, but it could be.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
RealAmberEyes said:
Just read THE SILMARILLION, and then tell us what impression made u. I've read it and for not spoilling ur reading,i'll just say it really made me think about the way the bible it!s written. The creation,the first most powerfull spirits, they were like guardians to the whole creation-in Valaquenta. The one that rebelled(Morgoth) and 4rm wich all evil creatures that appear in Lotr derived. So i got sooo amazed because it resembled the christian history of creation.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
seaprincess17 said:
telah diberi that the Christian story and themes played an important role in Tolkien's life I can see how similar themes would appear without conscious choice. I do not think Tolkien intentionally wrote LOTR etc. as an allegory.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
bibytuna said:
That is good so I can meet him in Heaven and yes
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
next question »