Book: I didnt really care for it....spent too much of the time with Bella whimpering over Edward. I didnt even get to enjoy the fact that Jacob was the main Cinta interest in the novel.
Movie: LOVED IT!!! Possibly even better then the Twilight movie. Taylor did such a fantastic job at playing Jacob that I am re-reading New Moon now, hoping that the saat time around Bella's whimpering wont be as noticable and that her and Jacob's relationship will make up for the lack of Edward.
As weird as it may sound I think Taylor's portrayal of Jacob may have just caused me to switch teams from Edward to Jacob lol.