I love Nathan <3

Lucas was a better person, Nate like Brooke came along way...I'm glad he transformed!!!

Nathan was a jerk to P.Sawyer

Nathan because he was sweet when it came to Hayley and Lucas was an asshole with Brooke

lucas started out good & then he turned into a jerk. nathan started out a jerk, but turned into a goods guy. so i like the person who becomes better, not worse.

IN SEASON ONE not now!!!!!!Nate was a jerk back in season 1, Luke was way better he may broke Brooke's heart but he was following his feelings he couldn't help it(im not saying bravo im just stating) Nate on the other hand intentionally went after Hales, treated Peyton like crap, cheated on her with Brooke(lets don't forget that although we found out in season 4) and i dont think that he was in love with Brooke unlike Luke who was in love with Peyton!!!!oh and yes he treated Luke like crap too!!!hmmmm..........................

i think Luke was better!!!!

First half of the season Luke,second Nate.;)

I agree..first half Luke but then Nathan!! ♥

i liked both in season 1

in season 1 I loved lucas...later I think I loved nathan more

lucas was a major tool who pretended to be all self righteous. nate was an ass but he was entertaining and awsome.

Nathan is my fav character but I have to admit that in s1 I loved Lucas, especially in the first half.... In the end of the season I start loving Nathan more, untill today :D

lucas is always better than nathan...i mean ALWAYS...but i'm bias luke's my favorite and has been since the pilot

nathann <3

Nathan is better than Locas ..

In fact Locas is bad & ugly

Nate was my bad boy!

A badass Nathan vs. a cheating Luke? Not exactly a hard choice ^^

Easily. More depth and more character development