so..
Lucas hurt her
Tim is just .. u know tim
jake isn't the 1 for her ..
So Nathan .. because he's hot .. maybe .. I don't know she don't was a friend with haley .. so )=

Yea she would probably pick Nathan. =]
Because Lucas had hurt her.. She knew that Peyton would pick Jake. And she would never pick Tim. xD

If she was there on time she wouldn't pick Mouth, because Mouth wasn't on the list of boys for real.

Totally agree with you 2! <3

lmao im with ca_cat, but i went with mouth cuz i still kinda dont see her taking nathan.

why in the world would she picked lucas? she hated him at that time! i think she was a good enough person not to pick nathan since she did elp get haley & nathan together. she wouldn't have gone for tim, but peyton wanted jake, so i think she'd go for him. i guess no one remembers how much she hated peyton then. she was the reason she lost the guy she loved... she would totally have wanted payback.

^^^ Well see, remember what she told Peyton about rooting for Jeyton in 2x01? She said she was always secretly cheering for them because she wasn't in to Jake.

The reason i chose Lucas is because i think 1.) She would enjoy making him miserable as some payback but also because it was at the end of that episode that she told him she thought she was pregnant. I could see her using that time to talk to him about it.

Nathan for sure ;) I mean neither of the others were "possible" for her to take (except Mouth)

Either Lucas or Nathan.

but i loved with Mouth.Still dont think she wouldve picked one of these cause if you remember she wanted the other boy but she didnt have cash.