well i LOVE peyton but that would mean both my moms were dead & thatd just be too sad =( i also LOOVE brooke but i just like her as an only child you know, brooke & peyton are just only child people LOL. i would love to have rachel as a sister, it`d be so much fun!

i love peyton.her style n everything about her.

haley would make a great sister.

i want haley toooo . but i really like brooke ..

haley because peyton bores me and brooke is to dam fine

brokke is funny kind and sweet but also is haley but brookes has got good fashion sense

Brooke, Hello!!! She is beautifull, and I could borrow her clothes, its a no brainer!!!! I love that Blazer she wears in the Shooting episode!!! I want it so bad!

Brooke would be so cool!

i would love to have brooke as a sister!

i would love having brooke or peyton as a sister...but i figure i could get seriously free fashion advice and clothes. besides shes such a sweetie. and cuz shes bffs with peyton i would always be able to go over to peytons and learn her badass music and deep ways.

she's just such a caring person and i love that :)

Hayley as a sister, Brooke as a best friend