This contest was created by link, all credit goes to her.
She doesn't have time to keep up with it though so she suggested I move it to a new forum, that way I can keep it updated.

*Please read the rules before asking anything*

Rules
- Make your own icon of the topic chosen for each round.
- You participate every round by leaving a comment with the icon you made.
- After 6-7 days, I will make a pick with every one of the participants' icons.
- Each contestant can only enter with one icon per round.
- The winner of each round, will receive props, get his/her's name written on the winner list and have the honor of choosing next round's theme.
- Have fun!

If you've never made an icon before, or have no idea how or where, here are a few sites and programs you can try:
link
link
link

They must be square [even on all sides] not rectangular.
Icon sizes:
100x100
200x200
300x300

Please don't use someone else's fanart [ie: wallpapers, banners etc] to make your own icon.

Anyone can enter but I reserve the right to approve all submissions. If I suspect that someone is cheating by adding more than one icon per round, I will enter the icon of my choice. I apologize for these rather drastic measures.

The Winner List
Round 01 - Dean in the Pilot: link with link.
Round 02 - Castiel in Lazarus Rising: Castiel4ever with link.
Round 03 - Chuck in the Monster At the End of This Book: link with link
Round 04 - Castiel in Point of No Return: link with link
Round 05 - Sam in Mystery Spot: link with link
Round 06 - Dean in On the Head of a Pin: link with link
Round 07 - Bobby in All Hell Breaks Loose Pt.2: link with link
Round 08 - Gabriel in Changing Channels: link with link
Round 09 - Sam and Dean in Hell House: link with link
Round 10 - Young John in the Song Remains the Same: link with link
Round 11 - Bela in Red Sky at Morning: link with link
Round 12 - Jo in Abandon All Hope: link with link
Round 13 - Ellen in Good God Y'all: link with link
Round 14 - Dean in Dream A Little Dream of Me: link with link
Round 15 - Sam in A Very Supernatural Christmas: link with link
Round 16 - Ruby in Jus in Bello: link with link
Round 17 - Azazel in In My Time of Dying: link with link
Round 18 - Mary in What Is And What Should Never Be: link with link
Round 19 - Anna in Heaven and Hell: link with link
Round 20 - Dean in Live Free or Twihard: link with link
Round 21 - The Shapeshifter in Monster Movie: link with link
Round 22 - The Crossroads Demon in Crossroad Blues: link with link
Round 23 - John in Dead Man's Blood: link with link
Round 24 - Pamela in Lazarus Rising: link with link
Round 25 - Sam in Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things: link with link
Round 26 - Dr. Badass in Everybody Loves A Clown: link with link
Round 27 - One of Dean's deaths in Mystery Spot: link with link
Round 28 - Best Icon of Your Choice: link with link
Round 29 - Castiel/Jimmy in the Rapture: link with link
Round 30 - Metallicar in the Pilot: link with link
Round 31 - Bobby in Are You There God?It's Me Dean Winchester: link with link
Round 32 - Ruby in No Rest for the Wicked: link with link
Round 33 - Sam in Swan Song: link with link
Round 34 - Dean in In the Beginning: link with link
Round 35 - Sam and Dean in Tall Tales: link with link
Round 36 - Sam and Dean in Like A Virgin: link with link
Round 37 - Dean in Changing Channels: link with link
Round 38 - Ben in the Kids Are Alright: link with link
Round 39 - Adam in Point of No Return: link with link
Round 40 - Rufus in And Then There Were None: link with link
Round 41 - Misha in the French Mistake: link with link
Round 42 - Alastair in on the Head of a Pin: link with link
Round 43 - Meg in Caged Heat: link with link
Round 44 - Your favourite spirit: link with link
Round 45 - Dean in the episode of your choice: link with link
Round 46 - Your Favourite Angel in the episode of your choice: link with link
Round 47 - Sam in the episode of your choice: link with link
Round 48 - Meg in the episode of your choice: link with link
Round 49 - Jo in No Exit: link with link
Round 50 - Lisa in Let It Bleed: link with link
Round 51 - Dean and Castiel in the episode of your choice: link with link
Round 52 - Balthazar in the episode of your choice: link with link
Round 53 - Sam and John in the episode of your choice: link with link
Round 54 - Your favourite character in the episode of your choice: link with link

Round 55 - 2 female characters in the episode of your choice: link

Round 56 - the contest is currently on hiatus


link
link