come on!! none??

I PERSONALLY LIKE SOPHIA BUSH, any others??

reese witherspoon

NO DEFINATELY MAGGIE GRACE!!!tHERES NO COMPARISON

hmmmm, with dark hair?

It would be funny if Kristen Stewart played her

I like sophia bush.. But not Willa Holland..


Maybe Megan Fox?

I agree Sophia Bush or Megan Fox.

yeah i dont know why i said willa, sophia looks alot more the part

Hey guys, I'm from Brazil and I read the book in english and loved. I think that Megan Fox would be a good Melanie. She did a gret job at Transformers.

My e-mail is lilita_venus@hotmail.com.

i would like to do some friends

i think sophia bush or missy peregrym from "stick it"

Sophia Bush of course! She'd be perfect.
She played a lot of strong character; The hitcher, Stay Alive, One Tree Hill ...

I like Sophia Bush or Alice Greczyn link

What about Natalie Portman?

I like Megan Fox but I think my first pick is Odette Yustman.

Selena Gomez ? She's a really great actress, but I don't know if she's too young? Maybe she'll make a great young version of Melanie.

I could see Odette Yustman, but I'm still partial to Eliza Dushku.

i can see eliza, but film whys i see keira knightley, she can do tough shit (melanie) and sensitive type (wanda) I reckon she could do the film with the rough and readyness the story will require, whereas most people are suggesting girls who only look good in vast amounts of makeup

Definitely Odette Yustman! No one else looks more like Melanie!

Olga Kurylenko-The Bond girl? I mean Mel's hair was cut short after Wanda was inserted, wasn't it?
so i think the look fits

Def. sophia bush
she would be an amazing melanie

Sophia Bush. Not my first or top 20. I think maybe someone who looks more like Kiera Nightly plus she's a good actress. Mel needs to look hard from living a hard life but also vulnerable and 17yrs old. Its a hard pick.

can some1 post a pic of sophia bush i cant picture her as for megan fox i would only see transformers odette yustman looks the closes to the girl i pictued reading the books but funny enough i was thinking if selena gomez could fitt the role today wow- da-ja-vu

I'm really not into Sophia Bush at all and I think Megan Fox is a bad actress!!! The actress who plays Mel needs to have depth of character...for me Hannah Taylor Gordon is exactly how I pictured Mel in the book and she's an amazing actress...doubly whammy lol! link

odette yustman younger megan fox. softerfeatures.

Biggesthostfan...i totally agree with your pic for Mel!! Hannah Taylor Gordon would be just absolutely perfect for me!

Yeah I think Odette looks like Megan fox,too.I think Megan is also a very beautiful actress but everyone is saying she's a bad actress.Megan fits the decription of Mel,too but Odette seems more graceful .

Hannah Taylor Gordon is by far the best suggestion i've heard yet for the part of Melanie. Odette is just a bit too blaa and Megan is double blaaaa...they just don't seem to 'fit'!

I know what you mean about fitting, kinda like Cinderella's glass slipper...only one actress can truley fit the part of Melanie! My money's on Hannah Taylor Gordon too.

I saw Hannah Taylor Gordon's picture and I don't think she fits the description of Mel at all.

I couldn't disagree more with 'kuncuyung' if I tried! Hannah Taylor Gordon seems just perfect to me, exactly how I picture Mel...

What if Melanie was played by a black girl

again this is another actress from the CW but Jessica Stroup(90210) is melanie stryder for me