bella can hav edward
ill keep jacob for my self =)

I love them both but i gotta pick Edward.
Jacob is a little obnoxious.

Team Jacob all the way x)

Team Jacob 4ever <3

Wow, diverse I like it x I'm Team Edward in the books because I think he is the better person, I think jake can be a little obnoxious at times (sorry!), but I'm Team Jacob in the movies, because Taylor Lautner is uber hot and him and Kristen look sooo much better together x That's not RPatz's fault, it's just the way it seems to me x :D Thanks for commenting guys x

I agree, AliceRoxx. I love Edward in the books, but I don't really like Rob's portrayal of him in the movies. He's too self-loathing and I just don't like his yellow eyes. I am a huge RPattz fan, but I gotta say I think Taylor is a better actor and the chemistry between Taylor and Kristen is better than Rob and Kristen. But I'm a forever book Edward fan!!

GOOOOO edward all the way

Haha my sentiments exactly drgroz! We're totally on the same brainwave x Yh I just think he hasn't quite understood the character as well as he could of, whereas Taylor Lautner brought the right kind of approach to Jacob. Yes, if only the book version of Edward were real *sigh* x

I HATED JACOB IN TWILIGHT and loved Edward but then later on in the books I changed my mind to Jacob all the way!
&&& I'VE ALWAYS HATED EDWARD IN THE MOVIES!!!
TEAM JACOB FTW!!!!!!

Yh I see where you're coming from totally gossip-girl999! I didn't like Jacob in Twilight either, I thought he was just interfering in something he didn't belong in! But then when Edward left he was so nice to Bella, he always forgave her, no matter what she said and I thiink he's a really sweet guy! x Yep, I h8 RPatz, so I've never liked the movie Edward!

Now, now, don't be hatin' on RPatz. He's just not Edward... I didn't really even have an opinion of Jacob in Twilight. He wasn't even there much. I think he's kind of a jerk in Eclipse too, but Taylor does a great job!!!

Haha lol well maybe not h8.. but I do sorta think he's a bit of a tramp..soz! x
Yh Taylor does a great job. Anyone got any suggestions of who would have made a better Edward then? x

I think, looks-wise, he's the perfect Edward. I just don't like the way RPatz portrays him - very tortured and self-loathing. He's fun in the books (well, maybe not New Moon) and romantic and there's great chemistry with Bella. I just don't see that in the movies. Maybe Eclipse will be better. He needs to lighten up a little...

Yh that's how I see it, because in Twilight, after the innitial kiss, he lightens up a lot and starts to think it will be okay after all, and he was happy at the end of New Moon, because obviously Bella was alive. He's just so miserable! And yh he hates himself so much, and maybe he is like that, but we're not meant to see that, because he hides it so he doesn't upset his family! x

Oh and yeah, they're relationship does seem rather forced, it's supposed to natural, chemical, but they act kinda like they are forced to be together or something x

team both i cant decide

More like don't care!!

Always EDWARD. FOREVER !
Because Jacob is so pushy & sassy.
I hate him.
Jacob/Taylor sucks !!

Agreed with vera_love.

I LOVE Edward in the books, but in the movies, I just feel plain sorry for Jacob, because He helped Bella get through Edward leaving, and Then Bella just said that it would always be Edward that she picked.

Yes, I totally agree with you Cullen61! In the books, I seemed to be biased and I just couldn't grasp Jacob and his viewpoints properly, yet in the movies, I see right into the character, and really connect with him on a level I can't in the books.