who tkinks tigerstar should have been mates with bluestar instead of oakheart?

Heh...Im sorry to discourage anda but I'd have to disagree with you. The reasons for this is:
1)Tigerstar is younger than Bluestar
2)He was ambitous and power hungry
3)He TRIED TO KILL HER AND ALMOST SUCCEDED SO HE CAN BE LEADER!!!
*I doubt Bluestar would even want to look at a cat as evil as Tigerstar better yet become mates with him! Even though I Cinta my Tiggerbunny *hugs tight* That doesn't mean I'd take up for him when he is wrong. And in this case I want to say no he shouldn't be with Bluestar instead of Oakheart.

P.S:Thats just my opinion..

~Little Eaglet

This soalan does not belong here.
anda should ask this in a pick/poll.

Never!He tried to KILL HER! dimwit.

Wait, that doesn't sound right. I mean that it sounds to me as if Tigerstar and Oakheart were mates. Oh, and, I say NO!!!!!!!!!! IT WOULD HAVE RUINED THE STORY!!!!!!!

Um HELLO? Ding, dong! Tigerstar is EVIL!!! Why would anda want he and Bluestar to be mates? I'm sure Bluestar was happy with Oakheart and Tigerstar was happy Sasha and Goldenflower. This is the worst soalan i EVER ANSWERED. I don't even think this soalan is legal!

NO WAY!

I think I know why tigerstar went evil. Did anda guys know that tigerstar Lost all his littermates as a kit and yet, he was the weakest. THistleclaw made him even lebih evil. If bluestar took him as a mate, why am I even answering this question?!? anda MUST have bees in your brain if anda think tigerstar and bluestar could be together!!!! Tigerstar tried to KILL Bluestar!!!!!!!! How can anda be so moused-brain!! So NOOOO tigerstar would have not been a better mate and still I dont think Oakheart was great either! The BEST mate for Bluestar would have been, Thrushpelt, and anda could tell he really like Bluefur errr BlueSTAR. THAT is what I think

NO!!!

that would have ruinded the story

Um No

NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
PLEASE gag me with a spoon GROSE

ok if bulestar went crazy when she found out her deputy was evil but if he was her mate 2 she would...uhh ohhh RUN KIDS SVE URSLEF WAIT BLUESTAR NOOOOOO

not me if anda do then anda are crazy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

UH HECK NO! I mean they could have been if Tigerstar wasn't EVIL!

what the heck kind of soalan is that, anda dimwit?! that would have ruined the whole story! and hello, he is evil and tried to kill her! hes bloodthirsty and powerhungry.you are such a nit!

that would just be crazy!

i think that tigerstar SHOULD NOT be mates with bluestar

Uh... GAG!!! I swallowed this gum! Yah, sure, she shouldn't have been with Oakheart, either. Sorry, but, did write this soalan to kill me? Ya, he didn't go evil, evil until latr. But anda mustve read Bluestar's Prophecy sejak now, he was a bad cat since the hari he was born!
I'm sorry but that's how it is(and Bluestar's like a gillion years older than the runt)!

NO WAY!!!!! THISTLECLAW WAS EVIL AND MENTORED TIGERCLAW INTO AN EVIL CAT!!!!! IF ANYONE THINKS THAT TIGERCLAW SHOULD HAVE MATED WITH BLUESTAR, THEN THEIR CRAZY!!!!!!!! BESIDES, AT LEAST ONE OF BLUESTAR'S KITS WOULD'VE TURNED OUT EVIL, JUST LIKE THEIR FATHER, SOMEHOW. I'M SURPRISED THAT GOLEDNFLOWER LOVED HIM!!!!!

NOT a good match...

i Cinta bluestar and if she was mates with tigerstar i would go crazy

If that happend Bluestar would have died a lot sooner

I don't think it would've ever worked.

I think she should of been because she would of stayed loyal to her Clan. Also hes only blood thirsty because ThistleClaw taught him. If Thistleclaw didn't teach him he would of been a nice and loyal cat. And also if he did go with Bluestar he might acutally turn good.

Tigerstar is better with Sasha because she never knew of his dirty ambitions until the end. And Tigerstar is much younger than her; she was a warrior while he was a kit. And she always was suspicious of him after Goosefeather had such horrible hopes for him.

i dont think tigerstar was ever mates with oakheart. if he was then LOL but i dont think it happened.

NO!

Why?

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!