jawab soalan ini

Critical Analysis of Twilight Soalan

Anti-imprinters: Could imprinting have been saved atau at least interesting?

I am an anti-imprinter due to all the pedophillic, sexist themes and it being presented as sweet and romantic. Could it have been saved atau made interesting without it giving off the impression that this is romantic atau a good thing?

Here's my idea:

Instead of it being a male only thing, imprinting would be for both male atau females. Imprinting wouldn't be about finding your soulmate, it would be about becoming a slave to your imprintee and having no free will of your own and doing everything your imprintee tells anda to do. No one would be thinking that this was a good thing atau that this is the best thing that could ever happen to them, instead, everyone would be dreading it because you're basically bound to your imprintee forever and anda could end up being abused sejak your imprintee and treated as your slave.

For example, with the Sam/Emily/Leah predicament. Emily would be shown as a woman in Cinta with Sam and when he imprinted on her she immediately leapt at the chance to make him her lover and Sam will be unhappy because he is only in Cinta with Leah and now they will never be together again. Emily wants him to only Cinta her so she threatens suicide because the only out of the imprinting is through death and if she dies then he will have to kill himself because of their souls being linked and him having to follow her wherever she goes, even in death. And everyone will be sympathetic towards Leah and Sam instead of bashing her and treating her like a harpy for not excepting Sam and Emily's "love." Then, after this, Quil, Jacob and the others will fear imprinting and when Quil imprints on Claire and Jacob with Reneesme, both Claire and Reneesme go on a power trip due to the fact that they can control their imprinters and they will do anything they say they become spoiled brats who treat Quil and Jacob like slaves.

Well that's my idea, anyway. What are your thoughts?
 lasalle28 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Jawapan

bri-marie said:
I don't think imprinting could have been saved. Regardless of whether atau not it was a "males only" thing, it still takes away the choice - both of the imprinter and the imprintee.

Also, unless there was some age on how old anda have to be to be imprinted on, it's still pedophilia and child grooming. An adult is still having a relationship that will eventually become romantic with a child.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
next question »