HOW CAN anda HATE HARRY POTTER?! 

i didn't even read this whole thing...but it was a bunch of crap...

baseless claims.

If this person starts talking about how amazing Twilight is, than at least we'll all know it's all fake.

Gosh... what a loser...

Useless trash. That I now hate.

I think the person who made that site...is ever so slightly immature.

And I think it's annoying how he/she assumes we've never read any other fantasy.

That was so ridiculous I thought it was a troll. (Like that Preppygurl chick who was posing as an immature Twilight fan.) But then I realized she(he? I think it's she) was serious.

Just because we read Harry Potter DOESN'T mean we don't read OTHER Fantasy books! I swear I'd already read half the books on the list.

What the fuck is she talking about? She really is a troll.

*agrees with you all*

I agree with every comment above!

Me too, I've read Coraline, Narnia, and numerous others!!!

I love how his/her critiques are vague and impersonal. "Same lazy plot points." How? What books did it "knock off" and how? The whole point of this site was for him/her to express her dislike, but she never once gives an actual reason.

Ironically, I dislike most of those books she recommends. I've read LOTR, The Chronicals of Narnia (I like the movies a lot better), A Wrinkle in Time, and The Golden Compass. The Golden Compass is the only series that I somewhat enjoyed. The rest I could not stand.

Also, I thought her analogy "It's like loving McDonald's because you've never had lobster" completely stupid and irrelevant. Cows and potatoes have nothing in common with shell-fish. And, again, ironically, I can't stand any type of sea food - not the smell, not the taste, not the texture - and if you gave me a choice of lobster and McDonald's, I'd take MickyD's any day.

I think this is just another case of a close minded, ignorant person. People have different tastes. Just because she didn't like HP doesn't mean that everyone who does hasn't read her idea of good literature.

The only good thing about this was the Narnia part ;)