Every time I watch this scene I'm so confused sejak Brooke's arguments...
"The last time anda try to STEAL my boyfriend". Steal boyfiend? Like boyfriend was a thing, without will, emotions & autonomy that anda can just take away? This sentence totally makes boyfriend a thing.
"He's on the door Peyton, on the damn door under me!" The same thing... Like Penulisan something down make them valid... anda can't just tell someone belongs to anda and take it for granted, not concering reality & other people feelings.
"But anda like him!" Yeah, it's a crime. Like anda could decide "From this moment on I don't feel Cinta anymore". anda can't feel guilty because of feeling. Truth is only acts can make anda guilty.
I felt sorry for Brooke, but this speach was so much out of place... I know how sad & angry, but just listening to her speach makes me like "WTF... Are anda hearing yourself...? Hope not, because it would scare you..."
I think Brooke may have overreacted. So she was hurting she didn't need to SLAP Peyton and then cut her out of her life. Peyton had the best intentions, she was very confused herself sejak her own feelings. The boy that she thought she loved realized before she did, that she was still in Cinta with Lucas.
Brooke berkata she's been going through alot lately. Did she find out she was adopted, and then her birth mother came back to see her. And then find out that her mother is dying of cancer, and then dies. And then gets shot. I think Brooke should cut Peyton some slack. I still can't believe that Peyton didn't see a counsellor sejak that time. She didn't need her best friend cutting her out of her life. When Brooke slept with Nathan years lalu and never told Peyton about it. She slapped her with that knowledge.(that's a really low moment for Brooke's character) I think if Brooke had been through even half of what Peyton has been through, she wouldn't be as much of a jalang, perempuan jalang that she was.
Sorry to Brooke and Brucas fans. But I hated Brooke in that moment and a lot of the moments in season 4. Brooke infuriates me sometimes. like with the conversation between Haley and Brooke "she lets one little stalker into her life and we all get screwed." "Brooke some of us actually have real problems." hei Brooke acts like her boy problems are like death problems. She's a bit of a drama queen, don't anda think?
Anyway aside from all that, I actually loved Brooke except in this episode and in some bits in season 4. But other than that I actually Cinta Brooke. She used to be my fave character on One pokok Hill, and Brucas used to be one of my fave couples. Then Brooke herself changed my mind. She let me down. She was just such a jalang, perempuan jalang then. I don't get why she had to be so mean????? If i had a friend like Peyton, I wouldn't treat her that way. I know Peyton has stuffed up in the past. But she's always been repenting for that. Anyway, can anda blame her? People who have been through that much crap in their life deserve to stuff up a little. She was just a kid. She was 10 years old when her first mother died. 17 when her birth mother died. When Haley's mum died, nobody told her that she was a jalang, perempuan jalang about her mum dying when she was. And Haley was a grown up. Peyton was just a kid.
God anda people can be so harsh towards Peyton that it's unbelievable. Maybe anda need to go through some of those things. See what it's like when everyone hates anda for whining about your shitty life, even though anda have solid reason to whine about it.
I think I'm biased in this. Not sejak being a Leytoner. but because I relate to Peyton more. I've been through very similar situations. Trust me peoples, it's hard living in the world with the crap that Peyton has to deal with, Leta lone dealing with stupid friend and boy troubles.
I'd rather have Brooke's troubles than mine and Peyton's any day! Brooke needs to wake up and realize that her problems aren't so bad!!!
I think your thoughts on this argument are gonna differ depending whether you're a Brucas atau Leyton peminat to be quite honest there is gonna be some bias.
My opinion on the argument is that Brooke was completely justified. For starters Peyton did NOT have to tell Brooke the way she felt about Luke. She could see how happy him and Brooke were and she knew telling Brooke could risk ruining what they had. Also she knew that it took a lot for Brooke to trust Luke and Peyton after what they did to her. It was totally the wrong thing to say to Brooke. It made her feel like it was all happening again.
Another things which p*ssed me off is the way Peyton twisted Brooke's words. Brooke didn't say she didnt miss Luke she pretty much berkata she wasn't as dependent on him as she thought she was, which was a good thing. Peyton pretty much made out Brooke didn't Cinta Luke anymore even though her reaction to what Peyton told her must have shown Peyton how much Brooke loved him.
so yeh I did feel sorry for Peyton when Brooke slapped her, although I feel Brooke was completely justified in her actions and everything she berkata to Peyton.
Anyway Soph and Hil both did an amazing job in the scene and the fact that there are so many opinions on the scene shows how great and with so much emotion they acted it. They really moved all the peminat-peminat :)
But yeh there is always gonna be bias with this soalan :/
Why should Peyton have to hid her feelings? Why is it wrong to be honest? Look how sleeping with Nathan and not telling Peyton ended up.
And then a couple eppys later she broke up with Lucas, so at that point she had to be questioning her Cinta for Lucas. Everyone blames Peyton, but Brooke broke up with him, and Peyton waited to make sure Brucas was over b4 she even talked to Lucas.
"The last time anda try to STEAL my boyfriend". Steal boyfiend? Like boyfriend was a thing, without will, emotions & autonomy that anda can just take away? This sentence totally makes boyfriend a thing. Well yeah it's like someone wants to be with your boyfriend i mean to seduce your boyfriend how would anda feel ?
"He's on the door Peyton, on the damn door under me!" The same thing... Like Penulisan something down make them valid... anda can't just tell someone belongs to anda and take it for granted, not concering reality & other people feelings. Because Brooke at beginning of season 3 they made those lists to avoid to be caught up in a Cinta segitiga, segi tiga again but it seems Peyton didn't care.
Okay 1. I don't get what anda mean sejak "Steal boyfiend? Like boyfriend was a thing, without will, emotions & autonomy that anda can just take away? This sentence totally makes boyfriend a thing." Are anda saying Brooke is saying that Lucas isn't a person but an object? Because she's saying the last time anda ruined my relationship and cheated on me. When Peyton mencuri Lucas away...
2. He's on the door! They made those lists together to avoid the drama of a triangle. I mean it's not like those were set in stone and it wouldn't be a problem if Peyton had gone for anyone else under Brooke on the door but jeez not the person she was currently dating
3. Brooke isn't saying "you choose to like him anda bitch." She's so hurt and conflicted because Peyton is her best friend and in Brooke's mind she can't feel selamat, peti deposit keselamatan in her relationship while her best friend is hurting because of it. And she's also upset because Peyron even told her. There's no reason to share that unless Peyton was going to act on her feelings.
This is what I got from the scene and I hope this helped.
Okay guys what the hell was that .. Peyton was so bitchy at that time and anda can't just say "It's not wrong to hide your feelings" Yeah , it's not .. But it is when you're inlove with your best friend's boyfriend .. It's not fear to Brooke to say that , she was crushed .. And when Peyton kissed Lucas I was like ;OO .. I was so angry .. For the 100 time ,Peyton hurted Brooke AGAIN .. And if you're confused of her arguments , anda are because she was angry and confused and sejak the way it's just a moviee ;DD But I don't agree with anda ..