I’m NOT including anyone who has already played these characters in the stage version, otherwise Ramin Karimloo would be the Erik/The Phantom and I’d be tempted to have Sierra Boggess as Christine, despite being too old to play her in a movie (On stage age doesn’t matter all that much, unlike in movies), because they’re the BEST Phantom and Christine of ALL TIME! Sierra even managed to make a bland and flat character interesting with not just her incredible singing but her acting abilities as well. Anyway, here are links to all of these people singing. My number one choice is Josh Groban with Jackie Evancho not too far behind.

Singing
link Groban[/url]

link Evancho[/url]

link Fisher[/url]

link McDonald[/url]

link Carpenter[/url]

link Peters[/url]

link Downey Jr.[/url]

link Jackman[/url]

link Gad[/url]

All of these would be AMAZING! Bernadette Peters as Madame Giry would be my next choice.