I like Steven better, however I think Taylor will do well too.

I think Steven will be better for movies 2 and 3, but for the first one he looks too old. I think Taylor will be just fine. :)

that steven dude is how i picture wolf jake but taylor is a good young jake

yeah i agree with that Steven woul dmake a better Jake in 2 & 3 but Taylor will do better in Twilight for a younger Jake so yeah....

Taylor for younger Jake and Steven for older Jake. Jacob sounds hotter older than younger and Steven is one of THE hottest guys ever. Did you see him in The Covenant, he's hot, with long hair aswell. He had longer hair in Sky High. I didn't see it but my sister did and I saw pictures of him in it.

im so sad that Taylor Lautner is Jacob.
I was pretty sure Steven wasnt going to be Jacob, but still, i think they could have picked some one better than him. hopefully he'll do well.

steven is WAY too old for Jake.

and all the characters are signed a 3 film contract, so if they make a 2nd and 3rd film, the same actors will be playing them.

and honestly, by the time they actually came out with New Moon, it'll be about two years from NOW

earlyest.

and Taylor is already 16, that means he'll be 18, im SURE he'll grow up accordingly.

i think taylor would be great as a younger jacob, but steven would be perfect in film 2 and 3.

steven straight would be my first choice, but since taylor is the offical jacob i might as well like it

cowgirlfromhell is right, steven is better from the next two. HE'S HOTTTT! taylor is good for one though, he's cute i guess, he just needs a little more help to look fifteen.

steven should be jake!!! he would do much better than taylor

steven should totally be great, but guess what, taylors gunna do a great job, so Im real excited about him playing the part. it is what it is

hrmm not much of a jacob fan, but steven straight might be a little too old..but bot of them are pretty good

well... i would have to see Taylor's face to decide - but i think Steven looks a bit baby-like in my opinion *aargh* i don't like these baby-face guys. like Michael Ballack or so - but that's no offense to anybody - it's just my opinion :)

The movie is the movie, but my Jacob would look more like Steven.

Steven, dude. He's sooooooooooo Hot. The other guy kind of creeps me out. He's kind of scary looking.

I think he would be good for eclipse and new moon jake. i love Jake especially as Steven Straight.

He's good as younger Jacob. Then they need someone like Steven for the next movies :)

look at that frakinggg six packk!

(;

HAHA
OK TAYLOR IS JACOB OK??
GOT IT??
NOT STEVN STRAIT OR MICHAEL CAPON
THEY ARE JACOB WANNA BE'S
THATS IT... OK IM IN LOVE WITH TAYLOR
HAHA

I really think you all should understand
that I posted this question NINE MONTHS AGO.
Before Taylor was picked to be Jacob.

I have total confidence in Taylor.
I think he is absolutely adorable.

:p