What do anda think about the situation between Bella, Edward, and Jacob? At a point Bella believes to Cinta both for distinct motives, at the end should she have picked Jacob(and why) atau should she stayed with Edward (and why)?

I never got Bella's "I was in Cinta with two people. But it was Edward I couldn't live without." It's possible to Cinta different people, yes. But when it's true love?

anda can only have one in my opinion. And the whole time, Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse, it was Bella saying Edward was her life and she was nothing without him. At the end of Eclipse, she berkata she loved Jacob too. That made no freaking sense. It angers me still. If it's a brotherly Cinta then I completely understand, but Eclipse, it implied she loved Jacob intimately. anda can only have one Cinta when it comes to intimacy. I hated that Stephenie Meyer wrote it like that. Everyone has doubts, but this whole time, Stephenie Meyer had written Bella as a strong person intellectually. She had written Bella to be once she made a decision, there's no going back. She was determined. And Stephenie Meyer contradicts the traits of her characters throughout the story. Jacob is a safer option, but Edward was her only option. She didn't want anyone else. That's how I saw it, yet SM tried to make it seem like it was a huge decision.

Also, just to put it out there...I hated Breaking Dawn. The demon child eating it's way out of her stomach.... i loathe that. SM contradicts herself in that book too.

Wow, I could write an essay in response. The triangle, the "love", The Jacob/Edward etc... I could rant my life away.

But I'm going to say this, Bella should have ended up with Jacob, he may be flawed, but atleast he's realistic (for SM), he's kind and selfless, and is not emosionally unstable like Edward. I generally just prefer Jacob to Edward on so many levels.

Sorry for the cruddy response.

She should have picked Jacob, definetly.

At least he's not a stalker and she wouldn't have the glowing demon child..

I have never actually truly understand Edward and Bella's love. Right at the very beginning of Twilight, I felt that Bella first fell in Cinta with Edward due to his good looks.:/ Edward on the other hand finds Bella 'virtuous' and beautiful. *SNORT* I find it rather superficial.

However, I do Cinta Bella and Jacob's relationship in New Moon. If there wasn't any interference, I think that relationship could have develop into something even more... REALISTICALLY, something even lebih stronger than Bella and Edward's love. I find Bella and Edward's Cinta dependent on excuses like fate, destiny, etc., which I find kinda tacky.

*Watch video sejak QuixoticalFilms* Sometimes, I wished it turned out something like this... After much thought, I think I would prefer if the story ended with Bella and Jacob.