jawab soalan ini

Harry Potter Soalan

Lucius Malfoy's lapdog?


I don't really get what the reltionship between Malfoy and Snape.
Sirius called Snape "Lucius Malfoy's lapdog". And Umbridge berkata something like "and Lucius Malfoy always speaks so highly of you!"
I get that they were/are both death eaters, and that Malfoy was a prefect when they entered school, but i still don't understand.
Narcissa berkata that Snape was an old freind of Lucius's, but i didn't think Snape would ever consider him a friend.

What's their relationship? Is it a one-sided kind of aquantinship? atau is Snape just a friend of the whole Malfoy family?


*
I'd combine the awesome jawapan below. They were good Friends ans Hraesvleg said, but that didn't start at Hogwarts as BlackHound brilliantly reasoned.
delamico posted hampir setahun yang lalu
 MasterOfFear posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Harry Potter Jawapan

BlackHound said:
Actually, Severus had problems with James Potter and Sirius Black from hari one, before they even got to Hogwarts. It all started on the damned train. Lucius and Severus only spent one tahun in school together, and I highly doubt Lucius was protecting Severus. Severus didn't go to anyone for help; he was too proud, and too ashamed.

And honestly, while my Cinta for Sirius is a deep, undying love, I have to say that I don't put much stock in anything negative Sirius ever berkata about Severus. Remus knew Severus better than Sirius did, and he never berkata anything like that. Sirius just had to have something nasty to say about Severus, and anda have to remember who he was talking to at the time. Harry, Ron and Hermione, and Sirius flat told them that he didn't know anything about Severus ever being a Death Eater! So...Sirius talked lebih than he knew.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Okay, disregard everything Sirius says about Snape. Got it.
MasterOfFear posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Interesting. I like that answer. :)
kkbb97876 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Hraesvelg said:
It's an interesting question. I think they were friends. Look at the things Snape did for Draco. And Lucius, how could he benefit from being Friends with Snape? Snape is poor and he's not a pureblood. Lucius doesn't/didn't really need Snape at all. Lucius obviously treated Snape well in school and probably lead him to the group of students who would eventually become DEs. Snape was, I think, lucky, when he had Malfoy to watch his back in school. It seems that his problems with the Marauders started when he had no one to cover his back (that's at least how I interpret Sirius' words about Snape being Lucius' lapdog). All in all, I think they were really friends. At least I wouldn't find it strange. Lily and Lucius were possibly Snape's only Friends - one was on the good side, the other on the bad side (which just shows how Snape was always in the gray area).
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
next question »