jawab soalan ini

Harry Potter Soalan

For those who have seen Part 2

Im hearing a lot of rumors going around. Can someone pasti (or dissprove) them for me?

Severus Snape was *cut before being bitten sejak Nagini?

Several scenes were missing from the Prince's Tale. Which ones?

Voldemort's death. How diffrent was it from the book?

The shell cottage scene between Ron and Hermione thats been buzzing around. About Ron trying to heal the "Mudblood" scar on Hermione's arm with the dittany. Yep, that fluufy little thing..was it there?

I wouldnt ask but Im not going to get to see it for a while. (MASSIVE change of plans. I was supposed to go Friday.)
 Misguided_Angel posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Harry Potter Jawapan

bendaimmortal said:
1.) I'm not sure what that means but Snape does get bitten sejak Nagini multiple times, but the bites are not shown on screen.

2.) I can't remember all of them from the books, so I can't answer this one.

3.) The only similarities were that Nagini was the last horcrux to go and he died to his own kedavra. But ithappened in lebih bombastic way. And his dewad body didn't remain. And there was no discussion between him and Harry and no circling around each other like wolves.

4.) Can't recall it being there but there was so much going on in the film that I might have missed it.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
Shelly_McShelly said:
1. It appeares as though Voldemort 'cut' snape before he set Nagini on Snape, but he does die from being bitten sejak the snake.

2. A couple of the scenes from Snape's past were missing, but i think that they got all the important parts in. I dont quite remember everything from the books, but they missed out a couple of bits that invovled Petunia, and a couple of scenes from Hogwarts invovling James, but anda get the general picture of it.
they do tunjuk the part where Snape goes to Dumbledore after he finds out that Voldemort is after Lily and he asks for Dumbledore's help.

3. In the book, Voldemort dies from Harry's killing curse but in the movie it looks as though he dies from his own curse which somehow rebounds back onto him. also, his body doesn't remain and he kinda falls to pieces which all kinda float away. It's a bit wierd but i think they were trying to make the scene lebih dramatic.

4. As for the last point, I dont really remember anything about Ron trying to heal the scar on Hermione, but if they did put that in the movie, it'd only be a really small part.

Anyway, i hope this helps
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
LadyNottingham said:
**SPOILER ALERT**

Severus Snape was cut before being bitten sejak Nagini?
=> Yes, Voldemort seemed to have used a non-verbal Sectumsempra before siccing Nagini on an already weakened Severus. Poor Severus...

Several scenes were missing from the Prince's Tale. Which ones?
=> Many like the Hogwart Express, the issues with the Marauders, the "Mudblood" scene. But this is not the most important in terms of what Harry needs to know. Other scenes were added which provide a very touching moment and an interesting outlook on Severus. For example : his taking Lily's letter at Grimmauld Place, his breakdown in Dumbledore's office, are not shown. But Severus breaks down in the Potters' house and that is really heartwrenching. Otherwise, the scene on the hilltop, the "Always" scene, when Severus learns that Harry is to die - which is the most important information - are included. I just wished they should not have rushed that part. I had this feeling it was. But all in all, it's OK.

Voldemort's death. How diffrent was it from the book?
=> He crumbles like Quirrell, stone-like, before disappearing in smithereens. But it works. However, I missed the part when Harry explains to everyone present that Severus was Dumbledore's man and always fought against Voldemort. I would have loved to see Voldemort make a double take at that piece of news. (Well, he was already much shaken sejak Harry springing up to life !)

The shell cottage scene between Ron and Hermione thats been buzzing around. About Ron trying to heal the "Mudblood" scar on Hermione's arm with the dittany. Yep, that fluufy little thing..was it there?
=> No, they directly go to the essentials : talking with Griphook and Ollivander about Gringotts and the Hallows. Which is a good thing, in my opinion. There's also a moment about Hermione that holds a hair from Bellatrix for the Polyjuice Potion. telah diberi what had happened in 2nd tahun to her, she confirms she's sure it is Bellatrix' !

Hope that will help. I read again the last chapters of the book these past few days and I saw the movie yesterday.


select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
:D Thanks. It good to know that not to much has changed. Was the meadow scene in the prince's tale? Where Sev and Lily talked about his father not liking magic?
Misguided_Angel posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
No, it is not.
LadyNottingham posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
:( Aww. Ok. I wish it was, but at least I have the book!
Misguided_Angel posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Percy___Jackson said:
I'm going to see it tonight at midnight!
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Me too!
kitty104295 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
I did see it at midnight
Thecharliejay posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »