I would have chosen the phantom because he is soooooooooo hot!!!!!!

Raoul is so dumb! I <3 the phantom! He is so much better than Raoul!

The Phantom for sure!

Gerald Butler is totally HOT!!

Well his singing voice is better than the other guy. If I was with him I would make him keep the fake hair and mask on.

e loves her more

Of course Erik. He is so hot and can sing. Raoul can't sing worth a dang and he isn't very hot at all.

The Phantom

Erik, while very sexy, was a creeper.

Who'd want to marry someone who was selfish and you wouldn't know whether you'd wake up dead or alive?

The Pahntom is much hotter ( I hate Raoul's hair)!!!

The phantom isn't selfish! All he thinks about is Christine the, the love of his life!

HAHAHA Raoul dont even get a picture...

@faithinChrist:

HES NOT SELFISH!!!! Raoul was selfish!! the phantom let christine go!! how in this dad gum world is that selfish!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
and the phantom would NEVER kill or hurt Christine!! he loves her too much!!!!! raoul was selfish bc he comes in there acting like hes known Christine all his life when he hasent! just bc u know some one as a kid doesent mean u know them now!! raoul wanted to take christine away when she clearly did not want to go..and he used her as bait thinking that he was smart enough to stop the phantom..pssshh wat an idiot!
Raoul was a priss...and a shallow person! if he really loved Christine he would listen to her! not boss her around! she tried to warn hm but NO!! Raoul's gonna be all "brave" and try to stop the phantom! yeah, so raoul was the one who caught the opera house on fire...

i want a man that would kill for me! the phantom loves Christine which is why he let her go...i wish he haddent and just kill raoul...

WHY OH WHY COULDNT RAOUL JUST DROWN!!!??
oh and he left her to get his sword just so he could defend himself! that fat guy that loves caletta didnt have a wepon but he still stepped in front of her! while raoul left christine to get his wimpy sword!
the phantom would NEVER hurt christine! that is a stone fact!!!

Skylar-Gray u r totally right. besides raoul is an idiot. he can't even figure out that the phantom will always love christine. Besides if i was christine i would've just picked the phantom of told raoul i knew he cared about me but that was years ago. he would just have to deal with that.

Personally I would choose musical Erik but not book Erik.

Sklar-Gray is right I haven't even thought about that (I think cause I'm always thinking about Erik . . .)I use to think that Raoul loved Christine but now . . . no more:)

I love the phantom! I think he is better for her.

the phantom saw everything in christine. he loved her soooo much. if i was christine, without a doubt i would totally spent my life w/the phantom.

of course i'd choose Erik :) but i dont want 2 be like Christine at all

Duh! Everyone loves Erik! He is better I mean he is the best. Raoul sucks!

Erik. I am completely and utterly and madly in love with him !!
<3

Raul is just a freakin wussy who can't sing

If I was Christine I'd go for the the Phantom as I think not only is he cuter on the outside but I think he has a real heart full of love inside!!! Ok so he gotta face infection as a child but thats no reason to not be loved by anyone I'LL HAVE HIM IF MY HUSBAND WILL LET ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i get why she was torn between the two... but seriously... come on. Once she kissed The Phantom he became a different person.. imagine how much progress he would have made if she just stayed with him and showed him love and compassion.

erik

Wow, so many shallow comments.. The Phantom is ugly that is the point :/ I think Patrick Wilson is gorgeous and better than Gerard Butler because he has this little talent of actually being able to sing his part... Gerard Butler is a disgrace to the Phantom part in my opinion, who casts someone who sings that badly in that role?!
But character wise, I would choose the Phantom because I like him better, I think he goes about loving Christine the wrong way but I don't think it's his fault, he is excluded so how would he know how to act like everyone else, he has his music and he is brilliant and I think he understands Christine more than Raoul can. Saying that I do not think that Raoul is a bad guy, it is sad to see him get Christine in the end, I mean he can have anyone, he's rich and handsome, it would be easy, but he does love Christine they were childhood sweethearts and he does care about her, I think his plan which is stupid I'll admit was to try and help her, she came to him scared in All I Ask of You and now he is trying to fix it..

he sings beautifully

E
Er
Eri
Erik
Eri
Er
E