Please note that these are my kegemaran adaptions, and I am not claiming that they are the best atau the most faithful. These are my personal opinions of Filem that I believe were were just as great, atau even better than the buku they came from.
#5 - Fried Green Tomatoes (1991)
Based on "Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe" sejak Fannie Flagg
There was a looot of book stuff that didn't make it into the movie. But since I saw the movie before I read the book, I didn't mind. The book provides lebih backstory on the town and the people in it, and includes a lot of characters that didn't make the movie, but I believe the right choices were made in the adaptation. The movie focuses on two major relationships: Evelyn and Ninny in the present day, and Idgie and Ruth in the past. The book is still one of my favorites, but the movie is a little lebih to the point, aside from kind of glossing over the whole by-the-way-Idgie-and-Ruth-are-a-couple thing. I do recommend Membaca it if anda liked the movie. (Plus, Sipsy's recipes are in the back!)
#4 - Bedknobs and Broomsticks (1971)
Based on "The Magic Bed-Knob" and "Bonfires and Broomsticks" sejak Mary Norton
Bedknobs and Broomsticks has been one of my kegemaran Disney Filem since I can remember. I Cinta everything about it. I've been putting off Membaca the book since I found out there was one, but I finally read it... and was pretty disappointed. The book gives a good basis for a story, but it's a very short children's book. (Well, technically, two children's buku - The Magic Bed-Knob, and Bonfires and Broomsticks.) Miss Price is barely in The Magic Bed-Knob, and the adventures are quite different. Oh, well, at least now I know, and I still have that perfect movie!
#3 - Divergent (2014) and Insurgent (2015)
Based on "Divergent" and "Insurgent" sejak Veronica Roth
I randomly decided to watch Divergent one hari for some light entertainment, expecting it to be a Hunger Games-y young adult knockoff. What I did not expect was to fall completely in Cinta with it. I watched the hell out of the library's copy, then ran to the store and bought Insurgent on the hari it came out, along with my own copy of Divergent. I read all three books, but they just didn't have the same spark that the Filem had. The buku focus on Tris, and contain some interesting background information on how the faction system works, but my expectations were very high, and they fell flat. Just words on a page. In the movies, the characters are brought to life through amazing actors who seem to understand and care about their characters lebih than the buku ever did, and their world seems real enough to live in.
(I have excluded Allegiant because of my negative feelings toward the final book, which were carried over to the movie.)
#2 - My Friend Flicka (1943)
Based on "My Friend Flicka" sejak Mary O'Hara
The movie My Friend Flicka was filmed on the ranch that the book's author, Mary O'Hara, lived on while she wrote the novel. (So there can be no arguing about the setting being perfect!) The biggest book-to-movie change is that Howard, the older McLaughlin son, has been replaced sejak Hildy, the young (and very loud) daughter of a ranch hand. She plays the same role as Howard, a tattletale and pain in Ken's keldai until Flicka falls ill, when she becomes surprisingly helpful. Obnoxious as she is, I do think Hildy livened it up. I'm always amazed at the training of Haiwan in old movies. There are no special effects yet. They can't just add stuff in with CGI. If anda saw it, it happened. Anyway, a wonderful adaptation that really captures the spirit of the McLaughlin family, and a great chance to see the real scenery! (But do not watch the sequels atau remakes, because they are garbage. Burn Flicka's scenery into your brain, and then just read the books.)
#1 - Holes (2003)
Based on "Holes" sejak Louis Sachar
I believe that Holes is probably the most faithful adaptation ever. It's perfect. The only real difference between the book and the movie is Stanley's weight, and since most Filem film out of sequence, sticking to that would have been impossible. (And also a terrible thing to ask a kid to do.) Perfect casting all around, each actor brought their characters to life in the absolute best way. Perfect, I say!
#5 - Fried Green Tomatoes (1991)
Based on "Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe" sejak Fannie Flagg
There was a looot of book stuff that didn't make it into the movie. But since I saw the movie before I read the book, I didn't mind. The book provides lebih backstory on the town and the people in it, and includes a lot of characters that didn't make the movie, but I believe the right choices were made in the adaptation. The movie focuses on two major relationships: Evelyn and Ninny in the present day, and Idgie and Ruth in the past. The book is still one of my favorites, but the movie is a little lebih to the point, aside from kind of glossing over the whole by-the-way-Idgie-and-Ruth-are-a-couple thing. I do recommend Membaca it if anda liked the movie. (Plus, Sipsy's recipes are in the back!)
#4 - Bedknobs and Broomsticks (1971)
Based on "The Magic Bed-Knob" and "Bonfires and Broomsticks" sejak Mary Norton
Bedknobs and Broomsticks has been one of my kegemaran Disney Filem since I can remember. I Cinta everything about it. I've been putting off Membaca the book since I found out there was one, but I finally read it... and was pretty disappointed. The book gives a good basis for a story, but it's a very short children's book. (Well, technically, two children's buku - The Magic Bed-Knob, and Bonfires and Broomsticks.) Miss Price is barely in The Magic Bed-Knob, and the adventures are quite different. Oh, well, at least now I know, and I still have that perfect movie!
#3 - Divergent (2014) and Insurgent (2015)
Based on "Divergent" and "Insurgent" sejak Veronica Roth
I randomly decided to watch Divergent one hari for some light entertainment, expecting it to be a Hunger Games-y young adult knockoff. What I did not expect was to fall completely in Cinta with it. I watched the hell out of the library's copy, then ran to the store and bought Insurgent on the hari it came out, along with my own copy of Divergent. I read all three books, but they just didn't have the same spark that the Filem had. The buku focus on Tris, and contain some interesting background information on how the faction system works, but my expectations were very high, and they fell flat. Just words on a page. In the movies, the characters are brought to life through amazing actors who seem to understand and care about their characters lebih than the buku ever did, and their world seems real enough to live in.
(I have excluded Allegiant because of my negative feelings toward the final book, which were carried over to the movie.)
#2 - My Friend Flicka (1943)
Based on "My Friend Flicka" sejak Mary O'Hara
The movie My Friend Flicka was filmed on the ranch that the book's author, Mary O'Hara, lived on while she wrote the novel. (So there can be no arguing about the setting being perfect!) The biggest book-to-movie change is that Howard, the older McLaughlin son, has been replaced sejak Hildy, the young (and very loud) daughter of a ranch hand. She plays the same role as Howard, a tattletale and pain in Ken's keldai until Flicka falls ill, when she becomes surprisingly helpful. Obnoxious as she is, I do think Hildy livened it up. I'm always amazed at the training of Haiwan in old movies. There are no special effects yet. They can't just add stuff in with CGI. If anda saw it, it happened. Anyway, a wonderful adaptation that really captures the spirit of the McLaughlin family, and a great chance to see the real scenery! (But do not watch the sequels atau remakes, because they are garbage. Burn Flicka's scenery into your brain, and then just read the books.)
#1 - Holes (2003)
Based on "Holes" sejak Louis Sachar
I believe that Holes is probably the most faithful adaptation ever. It's perfect. The only real difference between the book and the movie is Stanley's weight, and since most Filem film out of sequence, sticking to that would have been impossible. (And also a terrible thing to ask a kid to do.) Perfect casting all around, each actor brought their characters to life in the absolute best way. Perfect, I say!