jawab soalan ini

Harry Potter vs. Twilight Soalan

What are your bahagian, atas 5 reasons for not liking Harry Potter atau Twilight?

I don't like twilight because
1. The plot is thin an not very well written.
2. The characters are not very well developed
( I do think Jasper was the best character and his back ground story was great)
3.Bella whines to much and she really pisses me off.
4. Edward is a creepy stalker
5. The 'battle' in Breaking Dawn was cheep and lame. it was really boring to read.

What are your FIVE reasons anda do not like Harry potter atau twilight?

 Harrypotter148 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Harry Potter vs. Twilight Jawapan

bri-marie said:
1. I'm with anda on the plot of Twilight - it was very thin and not developed very well. Also, the general plot of "high school girl falls for vampire who also goes to high school" was extremely over-used.
2. I couldn't relate to any of the characters atau their situations (not the whole "he's a vampire thing" but their basic, basic situations). They, also, aren't very developed.
3. It seems to glorify the bad messages.
4. Anti-climatic ending of the entire series.
5. The mistakes - which I blame Meyer's editor for just as much as her, tbh.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
I agree it is over used. Gets boring after a while.
Harrypotter148 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
I agree over used plot
zanhar1 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
-Alohomora- said:
1. Bella. I'm not even going to get into that.
2. Breaking Dawn. Not going to start on that either.
3. The undevelopped plot.
4. How Bella gets every single thing she wants and has everyone wanting her.
5. Demotes feminism.

:)
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Demotes feminism. Thats a good one!
Harrypotter148 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
I hate how Bella always gets what she wants life doesn't work like that.
zanhar1 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
^agreed
AllyAM posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Gred_and_Forge said:
I don't like Twilight because:

1. The characters don't have any real flaws. Yes, it's fiction, but at least have some human flaws. Not everyone is a supermodel with nice cars and expensive clothing. Nor do we have at least 5 guys chasing after us at one time.

2. I don't like the first person POV in the stories because all we know is that a) Edward is perfect b) if anda don't like Bella, you're immediately the bad guy c) it's okay to give up living for a guy anda only knew for a couple months, etc. etc.

3. The plot is very weak and has been done before (Vampire Diaries, Romeo and Juliet, etc.)

4. Imprinting. Creepy much? I don't mind the Sam/Emily imprinting that much, but imprinting on a 2 tahun old and a new born is just wrong. Although it's not a romantic relationship at first, Quil and Jacob are what some people call child groomers.

5. Stephenie Meyer. She's such a smug person who thinks she's this amazing writer and puts down other stories and characters in berkata stories. She also can't handle criticism and has her brother read all her emails first before it gets to her. She can't even step up and defend her stories without getting offended atau sejak changing the subject.

I don't like Harry Potter because:

1. Too many deaths.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Very true.
emilyroxx posted hampir setahun yang lalu
GemonkDruid said:
Tope 5 reasons for not liking Twilight:
1. The sparkly vampires. DO NOT even try to convince me otherwise, with reasons like "it's original", atau "vampires are mythical creatures" atau some other BS like that. You're just wasting your time.

2. It's anti-feminist.

3. Bella Swan.

4. Edward "Right Man" Cullen.

5. Renesmee.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
anda don't like Renesmee???!!!
ros59 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
I think she's ok
zanhar1 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
kittyluvaxoxo said:
*sigh* I don't dislike either. Just because anda like one thing doesn't mean anda have to HATE the other.. even though i PREFER twilight does not mean I hate harry potter.. simple :|
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
although i agree with u on bella being too whiny xD
kittyluvaxoxo posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
i did not always hate twilight there was a point that i loved it but that was then
Harrypotter148 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
She never berkata that anda could only like one out of the two anyway. She asked for reasons why anda dislike them.
MissKnowItAll posted hampir setahun yang lalu
cassie-1-2-3 said:
I do not like the Harry Potter series because:

1.The wording/writing style annoyed me
2.A few characters were annoying
3.Violence/aggression/cursing (including immitation cursing)
4.I don't like the English vibe it gives off (Vibes, not people. It’s not a phobia either)
Since I don’t hate Harry Potter,
5.Being told that I should like it becuase my reasons are not valid enough for them is pretty annoying.

select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Never give up ;)
youknowit101 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
English vibe? But anda like the American vibe Twilight gives off? :/
Kylie90210 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Yes.
cassie-1-2-3 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
zanhar1 said:
Why I dont like Twilight

1. The Vampires sparkle Vampires are supposed to be terrors of the night not glittery faries.
2. The characters are too perfect I can't stand it I like my characters to have flaws.
3. It shows that abusive love, lust, infaction, and getting pregnant as a teen are ok.
4. It's unoriginal there are way to many vampire/human romances.
5. Bella can never seem to fight for herself she always depends on Edward atau Jacob.

Things I don't like about Harry Potter

1. Bellatrix died and at the hands of Molly Weasley!
2. Lavender Brown her character was annoying her Cinta for Ron was lusty and filled with infaction.
3. Dobby died he was a great character I don't see why his death was needed.
4. Alot of the parings I thought Harry should've ended up with Hermione Ginny with Neville and Ron with Luna.
5. Wormtail, he's a tratior and a coward.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
There basicly the plot of HP anda didn't like XD, I agree about Bellatrix, but I always imagine her death as revenge, in memory of Dobby.
RavenclawRocks posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
I thought her death was automatically made better sejak Molly swearing, it was well placed in my opinion and made that part seem lebih real
AllyAM posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
I hate Molly too, make that a doubble crucio. Yes I know it was supposed to be lust and I dont like that part.
zanhar1 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
AllyAM said:
1. Bella is annoying and whiny, she has it pretty great, a loving home, several guys like her (a lot), yet all she does is complain about her life
2. Edward, he's too perfect. It's sickening. I don't care if he only seems that way because it's from Bella's POV, no one is that perfect.
3. Jacob goes from an awesome character, once Bella officially chose Edward he becomes annoying and angsty. Also, he uses words like "loam" in his thoughts. No one thinks like that unless its seriously about farming, gardening, atau soil science.
4. Bella gives up everything in her life to be with Edward: Her family, her friends, college, to say the least (so, mostly just the morals it teaches)
5. PURPLE PROSE! It's annoying! Look it up of anda don't know what it is.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
anda rock.
hpr posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
d'aw thanks!
AllyAM posted hampir setahun yang lalu
snoznoodle said:
So I've been team Harry ever since I was about 8. I've also gone into what I don't like about Twilight about a billion times. So for a change I'm gonna say what I don't like about Harry Potter (keeping in mind it will probably always remain my favourite ever series).

1. The deaths in the last book FOR NO APPARENT REASON. I can understand a couple, like Mad-Eye - sure he died exactly how he would have wanted to. Even Fred I can tolerate. But Lupin and Tonks?! ARE anda SERIOUS? What good does it do having some of the most beloved characters lying dead without even saying how it happened? It's horrible. Basically I liked a character, and then they died. Starting with Sirius.

2. The epilogue. SO UNNECESSARY.

3. How much they changed some of the films. The fourth film in particular.

4. OK so my real problem was actually only number 1. Now I just need to fill up dot points so I'm going to say I know I'm going to hate when Snape dies in the last film. I am so attached to Snape Alan Rickman I think I'm going to make a real fool of myself.

5. The fact that over the years as I waited for the seterusnya book to be released I formed all these intricate theories about things such as Sirius' death and it turned out that I was looking waaaay to much into it. Although that is actually my fault. I was extremely disappointed all the same lol.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
Diasasis said:
My bahagian, atas 5 reasons for not liking Twilight(and I will try to be as original as possible)
1. There are too many borrowed plot-lines/details for me to think it's original story.(i.e. Vampire Diaries, Roswell, Buffy)
2. The characters are superficially flawed(i.e. bella being clumsy)
3. seterusnya to nothing is known about the villians, they're simply evil.
4. Lack of over-arcing plots to tie the buku together.
5. The ending of the series basically making the rest of the buku obsolete.(Jacob can't get with Bella, oh that's fine cause she's just going to give birth to your soulmate anyways.)
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
Darkshine said:
1. The prejudiced, bad, sick meesages it sends:

-'Blondes are eeeeevil!' (Caius, Lauren, Rosalie, James)

-'So what if guys do all the cool stuff!' *sexist alert*

-'Omg pedophillia, necrophillia and stalking are yomantic'!

-'Being personality-less and two-dimensional is nothing bad, actually it will make anda popular in school!' (Bella)

2. The horrible Penulisan and lame plot.

3. The lack of good characters, and if they exist, they are either 'baddies' atau 'boring, unneeded humans'.

4. The relationships in the series are two-dimensional, weird and in most cases disturbing.

5. The fact it ruined/changed the perception of Vampires and all the traditional traits they had in the history of literature.

PS.
Visit this. anda won't regret, trust me. v
link




-'And they all lived hapilly ever after, The End'
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Frozen Apples is awesome!!!
alexthedog posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
^ Of course it is! Did anda check out the "List of nicknames for Edward Cullen"?
Darkshine posted hampir setahun yang lalu
PotterLucy said:
1.The book was based on a dream and Stephenie didn't know how to develop it.
2.Bella whines to much and she really pisses me off.
3.It's stupid all that time that Bella had to choose between Edward and Jacob - supposedly, if she loved Edward, there was no choice to make. 4.The 'battle' in Breaking Dawn is lame and boring. Such suspense for nothing.
5.It's weird Jacob falling for his ex-love's daughter - Renesmee
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
sevendeadlysins said:
Twilight (I might as well have copied and pasted what other people said...)
1) Every time I thought it was going to get interesting, the problem was solved in the least interesting way possible. (Hey, guess what, Meyer, I've had lebih interesting dreams!)

2) Bella Swan. Really, everything about her. I think if we were all as stupid and naive as she was, our lives still wouldn't be as perfect as hers. God forbid there be even a little bit of reality in a fictional world.

3) The few interesting characters Meyer has, she tends to toss to the side and ignore. She likes to focus on the ones who are boring and lack real personality traits, and it pisses me off. There are plenty of other characters that could be sitting there watching paint dry and I'd still prefer to read about it.

4) Edward. anda don't watch a girl sleep when anda aren't even going out with her!!! anda just don't. And let's keep the PDA to a minimum, would anda please? Is it just me atau is he always uncomfortably close?

5) All the evil villains can die, sure, but none of the good guys can. The world is so perfect, which means if you're on the good side, anda get to live and life will be perfect for anda in the end! (Have anda read Deathly Hallows? I'm pretty sure lebih good guys died than Death Eaters, and it made for a generally lebih dramatic battle, which made it a BETTER BOOK.)

Harry Potter

1-5) The movies. They are my only real problem with the series. I Cinta them, I do, but the fact that they tend to be so different from the book is a bit distressing. Now, I can't complain about most of them because I thought they followed the best they could, including all of the most important information, but there were some that I think could have handled things a little better and a little lebih closely to the book... not mentioning any names... *coughHALFBLOODPRINCEcough*
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
exactly my feelings for the HP negatives
AllyAM posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Italktosnakes said:
I can't really pinpoint why I don't like it on the spot. I just remember Membaca it and not liking the keseluruhan vibe. Sorry to disappoint :L x
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
xDark_Angelx said:
What I don't like about Twilight:
1. The big words Meyer used. I hope I don't sound stupid here, but there's a limitation, I believe, to using "impressive" words. When Penulisan a story (whether a novel for kids atau EVEN YA), anda should at least use simple words ever once in a while; complicated words makes it less realistic. It didn't sound like I was in a 17 tahun old girl's perspective.
2. How well Bella is befriended and loved sejak almost the entire Forks HS. That's completely unrealistic; no person ever in a new school can have many people want to be their Friends suddenly.
3. How quickly Bella states she is in Cinta with Edward after just a week atau two into meeting him, and only speaking atau bein around him hardly a lot. I just don't believe in the whole "love at first sight thing, either." Also, the "love" is listening to Bella go on and on about Edward's "hotness" and Edward smelling her "amazing" scent and watching her in her sleep every night. That's not love; it's obsessive lust.
4. Bella's reaction to Edward leaving her. She fell into a coma; it's not right! She acted like a zombie for months! Just because her Cinta left to protect her from himself. She even jumped off a cliff to hear his voice. That's a really bad message for teenage girls coping with boys in the real world.
5. And, finally, Bella herself. She leaves her non-vampire Friends sejak the end, hardly remembering them, like they don't mean anything anymore now that she's with the Serigala Jadian and vampires. They must be much lebih exciting. She can be put in just about anyone's shoes easily (just about being the fact that she left her friends-I'm not sure if I would do that, but I hope I wouldn't if I were in her shoes)! She's super plain and dull.

Five reasons I don't like Harry Potter
1. Dumbledore is a cliche old guy who is wise and gives Nasihat to the troubled hero of the story. He even has the white beard! XD
2. Too. Many. Deaths! Sure, it's reasonable, I guess, since a simple curse could kill anyone, but why so many of Harry's loved ones? Why innocent people like Tonks and Lupin? Why Colin-Colin Creevey!?
3. I kind of hated the ending. I wanted to see everyone together again. I wanted to see what happened Hermione's parents afterward. I wanted to see how everyone dealed with the end of the war not 19 years later-maybe a week. But since I'm not the authoress, I can do nothing about it.
4. Sorry, but Hermione sometimes annoyed the hell out of me. She was always just so demanding and bossy. She acted like she was much older than she really was. I just hated it...
5. How Harry was loved sejak his parents-they were taken away. His godfather loved him-he was taken away. He only had his aunt and uncle-they hated him. They treated him so badly. Why did they have to take away all the Cinta from Harry? I would have loved to see even a cousin come to the house every once in a while and be nice to him. In the
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
*Muggle world, he's not treated like everyone good like him should be. God, I wrote a lot lebih than I wanted to. XD
xDark_Angelx posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
i agree with your 5 point
Harrypotter148 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
^To me, she like it in pretty much all the books. XD
xDark_Angelx posted hampir setahun yang lalu
bookworm117 said:
Why I dont like Twilight
1.The movies
2.Makes people go nuts (also when people think its good literature)
3. In Breaking Dawn nothing happens. Its like waiting for the roti bakar to pop up and realizing anda forgot to plug in the toaster.
4.Bella just gives up and dies without Edward. Seriously how long had they known each other.
5.When he sparkled the Buffy peminat in me died a little.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
wotcher-tonks said:
Why I don't like Twilight:

1. The messages it sends. (You can't live without a boyfriend, Women belong in the kitchen, etc.)

2. Bella Swan, the main character, is a Mary Sue, and a horrible role model.

3. Meyers Penulisan style. She used big words where smaller words could have worked better. Using big words doesn't really make anda sound smart.

4. Underdeveloped characters (Esme. All anda know is that she jumped off of a cliff after her baby died and she fell in Cinta with Carlisle. There are many others, but I won't get into them because that would take me forever.)

5. The useless 100,000 descriptions of Edward's cold marble lips. Who would even want to Ciuman cold marble anyway?

I felt like adding a sixth, so here it is!
6. Many of the peminat-peminat I know in person are phsyco freaks who go ape on anda when anda say anda don't like Twilight.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
HPfan236 said:
I hate twilight because
1) poorly thought out plot that is almost nonexsistent
2) no suprise very predictable
3) sexist females are weak in the book
4) No character depth
5) Bella angsa, swan the most bitchy mary-sue I have ever come across
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
NightFrog said:
For Twilight

1. The plot seemed a little scattered to me, and not very well developed.
2. Bella Swan- mostly starting from New Moon and onward. I can respect her a little in the first book because of her wanting to save her mom, but in every other book, I just did not like her.
3. Edward following Bella into another town, and watching her sleep- invasion of privacy, and I can't find it romantic in any way.
4. Breaking Dawn.
5. The characters didn't seem very fleshed out. Some of the backstories for Edward's siblings were good, but other than that, there just wasn't much else to them.

I have lebih reasons, but those are my bahagian, atas 5.

For Harry Potter

1. The fact that Voldemort's blood status was mentioned only once (Harry mentioned it to Bellatrix), but was never really discussed again. I mean, he is a half-blood wanting to rid the world of muggle borns and so on.. you'd think that would be important information.
2. The drama in The Half Blood Prince. I liked the book mainly because I got to hear lebih about Tom Riddle, and that Dumbledore died at the end (well.. I didn't 'like' that, but it was interesting for the story).
3. The rushed relationship with Ginny and Harry.
4. The way Voldemort was defeated. I expected a little something more, I guess. It was like "zap" and then everyone is cheering.. that's it.
5. The ending. I think a lot lebih could have been explained. It made me feel really empty.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
next question »