jawab soalan ini

Harry Potter vs. Twilight Soalan

Ok tell me this, Twilight fans!!

If Edward is sooo good and moral, why did he kill people?
Let me guess "BeycauSz thERE bAyed adn EdwearD kILzz BaYEd peollples!!11!!"

anda think killing bad people is good? If Edward is any smart, he would turn them into the police and let them take care of it!! anda can't take care of the law yourself! Killing is still killing and against the law!

Te same with Rosalie! Why didn't she just take those guys to the police???

Any explanations?
I only want GOOD answers. Nothing like "EdWEard Kan du watevR HeE wantZZZ Cuzs He's HwaTT"
*
^_^ Yay!! That was great!!
ladywyze posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
i know
hpgods posted hampir setahun yang lalu
 hpgods posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Harry Potter vs. Twilight Jawapan

cassie-1-2-3 said:
Lol.

Because Twilight doesn't take place in 17th centure Salem.

Edward can't just take someone off the street, drag them to a police station and say
"This man murdered someone."
They'll ask him how he knows them and Edward would reply with "Because... I just know" atau "becuase I'm a vampire and I can read minds" which would get the Volturi on him.

The same with Rosalie.
She can't wrangle up her fiance adn Friends and take them to the police station and say "These guys murdered me a while ago."

There needs to be reasonable means to detain someone. anda can't arrest someone just because someone tells anda to. Not always, at least.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
o......kay. That's weird
hpgods posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
^Not really, it kinda makes sense. :L x
Italktosnakes posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Yes, as in the Salem Witch Trials where if anda were accused of being a witch atau a vampire atau something else, they'd punish anda before you're proven guilty atau innocent.
cassie-1-2-3 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
GemonkDruid said:
Isn't that the same as if Harry Potter went to the muggle police because Voldemort killed his parents? *rolls eyes*

The police are good law enforcement, but frankly in Supernatural cases, they're totally useless.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
bri-marie said:
Because taking them to the police station wouldn't do anything. The police can only make an arrest when they have a warrant, when they catch the criminal in the act, atau when they have "reasonable grounds" for suspecting is person is atau has committed a crime. A Rawak person dragging another person in and going "He killed someone" isn't reasonable grounds.

Rape is hard to prove even on the best of days and, since Rosalie was perfectly fine (or she would have been when she dragged the men into the station) the police would have had no reason to make an arrest. No proof other than some Rawak chick claiming rape. Even back then, I don't think anything would have come of it.

Killing the wicked isn't accepted as morally wrong sejak everyone - hence why almost half the world still has/uses the death penalty.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
I don't think so
hpgods posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Don't think so what? That countries have the death penalty? That's a fact, sweetie. That's not everyone considers killing bad people to be wrong? That's a fact too. That cops won't arrest someone based on hearsay? That's a fact too.
bri-marie posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
How don't anda think so honestly are anda just denying it my 8 tahun old brother knows rape is hard to prove why because some girls maybe boys try to fake rape just to stir up trouble.
zanhar1 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
TrueTwi_hard said:
Okay, imagine this:

You're Edward Cullen, watching the night, listening to people's thoughts to find a murderer. anda find some, grap him and take him to the police.
'I heard this man killing a girl.' You'd say. Then the policeman would ask how, and anda have two options.
1) 'I'm a vampire, and my special gift is Membaca thoughts.
2) I was standing in a alley to find a murderer to kill.
Both will get you: First, in jail. Second, killed sejak the volturi.

Next:

You're Rosalie Hale, just changed. Your almost-husband left anda bleeding. anda would've died without Carlisle. So what do anda do? anda go to him and his Friends and get them to the police. They ask anda what they did. anda have only one option:
1) They left me bleeding in the jalan and I would've died if dr. Cullen didn't turn me into a vampire.
They would doubt your mental skills and get anda in a hopital. Also, anda would get killed bye the volturi.

So anda have actually no options. Yeah, true, anda could not kill at all, but anda can't ask em about that, ask stephenie.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Um no.
hpgods posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
anda spelled imagine and have wrong
hpgods posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
^ :D see? woo!
ImBooOK posted hampir setahun yang lalu
ArcticWolf said:
No offense, but Twilight peminat-peminat don't really talk like that anymore (at least not on this spot) so the examples were unnecessary. As other people have said, in any Supernatural T.V. show, book, atau movie, the police are almost always useless, unless they are in on the secret. There'd be too many soalan of "how" "when" and "where" that they wouldn't be able to answer, so basically even considering that option would be almost illogical. It would make lebih sense just to kill the guy. And anda also have to remember - these are Vampires we're talking about. Do anda think they give a crap about the law? They're immensely lebih powerful than humans, so wouldn't it make sense that they'd set themselves a bit higher than the human law?

select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
LinaHarrow said:
I agree with everyone else.

They're not going to be able to prove it to the police. And I think the law enforcement might be a skeptical bunch if the Vampires were to tell them the truth.

Also: He is trying to kill them for a reason. Do anda think those nasty, evil Vampires are just going to sit quietly in the backseat while Edward drives them to the police station? Yeah, I didn't think so. And if they somehow manage to get to the station, what about those police men? They could get hurt atau killed once the evil, non-vegetarian, hungry, brutal, dangerous vampire arrives.

sejak the way, anda spelled "because", "they're", "bad", "and", "Edward", "kills", "people" "!", "can", "do", "whatever", "he", "wants", "because", and "hot" wrong. (;
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
And "the". "Te same with Rosalie!"
cassie-1-2-3 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
^Exactly. And that even wasn't when they were trying to mock us.
LinaHarrow posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
And it may suprise you, not all peminat-peminat of Twilight like it because of Edward atau jacob..so I think the whole thing were the person berkata something about that at the bottom is just asuming things about us. (ps...love HP too so yurp)
ImBooOK posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
^That doesn't surprise me. I am a peminat of Twilight. And I think Rob P. and Tay L. are both kind of ugly. :/ (I Cinta HP too as well.)
LinaHarrow posted hampir setahun yang lalu
zanhar1 said:
Honestly same thing could be berkata for hp.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
ImBooOK said:
Edward does not kill people. None of the Cullens do? Sure Jasper wanted to take a chunk out of Bella in New moon but did he? No he did not. And to turn himself into the police would be retarded. I can see it now
"Guys, I am a vampire and stuff" .....*cricket cricket* and then that would just lead to the Volturi coming to him, and since Bella is like ALWAYS with him it would be putting her in danger because the Volturi (some of them anyway) want her dead. If anda were any smart...you would realize this, and anda would also have known that Edward and his family are animal drinkers...and Haiwan are NOT humans! I do not care at all for Edward atau Bella but I like Twilight because of Carlisle. So there...I told anda this. (sorry if I am being rude it is just that I have seen this come up once atau twice about the Cullens killing people)
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
...Edward killed humans shortly after he was changed. He left Esme and Carlisle and fed off humans.
bri-marie posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
.
ImBooOK posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
ooo. nvm then .lol
ImBooOK posted hampir setahun yang lalu
ladywyze said:
Na, I don't know. I'm not a peminat of Edward himself.

I don't have a very good mind to think of "any" sane explanations.

^^
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
next question »