What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Harry Potter vs. Twilight Do Anda Think Bella Is Clumsy Atau That She Has A Mental Problem?

53 fans picked:
BOTH.
BOTH.
   55%
(added by Lord-Voldemort)
clumsy
clumsy
   19%
she has a mental problem
she has a mental problem
   17%
Neither
Neither
   9%
(added by bri-marie)
 luv_warriorcatz posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

12 comments

user photo
who the f*ck trips over their own boots?
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
last edited hampir setahun yang lalu
 
user photo
she has a mental problem
tellymaster picked she has a mental problem:
There is something seriously wrong with Bella.
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
Karipoof said:
Can you say both, because I think so. She has a mental problem and is clumsy.
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
clumsy
cassie-1-2-3 picked clumsy:
Hm.. I'm almost as clumsy as Bella, but it's somewhat medical related. Nothing mental. My limbs are a little too long to have complete control over.

That's not the case for Bella, because she's short. I don't know why she's like that. I'm just talking.
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
Neither
bri-marie picked Neither:
Bella is said to be a klutz, but it's rarely ever shown. I think she tripped, maybe, three times in the whole series? Hardly a klutz.

As for the mental problem . . . She was depressed (and suicidal) when Edward left, but after he came back it all just went away. . .

@Karipoof: You can add answers.
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
BOTH.
Lord-Voldemort picked BOTH.:
Boooooth (I mean BOTH but, y'know, stretched out...not booth...)
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
she has a mental problem
DracoLuver picked she has a mental problem:
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
she has a mental problem
SerialFangirl picked she has a mental problem:
link

I don't know if it will work (I'm terrible with links and other computer stuff). Also, the link DracoLuver put up is good.

@luv_warriorcatz: I trip over my own boots/shoes/feet/toes... I'm very clumsy.
Bella just doesn't seem very clumsy to me. It's too inconsistent. She has klutzy moments, but I wouldn't say she's clumsy as a person.
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
BOTH.
sevendeadlysins picked BOTH.:
And this combination is not a good one, clearly.
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
Neither
HecateA picked Neither:
I think Stephenie Meyer just failed at defining her well enough as a character. I mean, I could tell you, "I am a robot" but when you look at me, you see I'm a young girl. Bella SAYS she's clumsy, but not much in her actions.

And this question was is Bella clumsy, OR does she have a mental disorder making her clumsy. So sociopath is not included (sorry if I got the name wrong)
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
BOTH.
SuperSnuffles13 picked BOTH.:
Well, it's not very consistent throughout the series, but we are TOLD she is clumsy, so I suppose she must be.
I don't think that this was the intention of the question, but I think she has a mental illness completely unrelated to her clumsiness. I'm no scientist, so I don't know many mental illnesses, but I think she has some sort of illness that makes people over-obsessed or desperate/suicidal.
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.
 
user photo
she has a mental problem
hrrypttrfn328 picked she has a mental problem:
Not mental problem, per se, but I always thought of Bella as having some sort of neurological disorder. She is clumsy to the point where it impedes on everyday life, puts her in almost constant danger of bodily harm or worse, and seems to be caused by nothing.
posted hampir setahun yang lalu.