Harry Potter

jawab soalan ini

Harry Potter Soalan

hey! how come Lily dies though James sacrificed himself for her the same way she did for Harry?????

*
rigth above
Jumin12 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
 illo posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Harry Potter  jawapan terbaik

bri-marie said:
Because Lily was offered a choice. She could have "stepped aside" and let Voldemort have Harry. But she didn't, she stayed where she was to try and protect her baby. James wasn't telah diberi that same choice.
 select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Best answer. I think the issue of choice is essential here. That's her choice that gave her sacrifice all the power it had. telah diberi the choice, James' sacrifice would have had the same value too. But as anda said, he was not telah diberi the choice AT ALL.
LadyNottingham posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Agreed!
jameswilson posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
And yet people tend to keep this bullshit about about James being a shit person.
delamico posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Jawapan

HecateA said:
I think it's because Voldemort would have killed James either way, whether he was trying to protect his family atau not. But Snape had asked Voldemort to spare Lily, so she could have lived, but she sacrificed herself.

Same thing with the woman that Voldemort killed with her 3 children in Deathly Hallows, for the wand. He would have ended up killing the 4, so it didn't matter if the woman was trying to protect her children atau not.
 select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
Which made Severus the most important character in the books, after Harry. Because of his request, Lily was telah diberi a choice sejak Voldemort. Hence the value of her sacrifice directly linked to her choice. Once again, Voldemort had understood nothing. He should have killed Lily right on the spot, without leaving her the choice, disposing of her like he had had with James. No choice, no sacrifice, no Harry, no story. Thank anda Severus !
LadyNottingham posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
Agree with LadyNottingham
karenmiller1972 posted hampir setahun yang lalu
Hiding 4 comments... click to show.
*
"If she means so much to,' berkata Dumbledore, 'surely Lord Voldemort will spare her? Could anda not ask for mercy for the mother in exchange for the son?'/ 'I have- I have asked him-' - Page 543, The Prince's Tale, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
HecateA posted hampir setahun yang lalu
HaleyDewit said:
I think it is because the Cinta for your child is different than the Cinta for the person anda romantically. There's no Cinta like a mother's Cinta for her child.
 select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
In some Eastern traditions, it is berkata that to tunjuk how much He loved mankind, God created the Cinta of a mother.
LadyNottingham posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
That's one of my kegemaran things to come utama to school to.
HecateA posted hampir setahun yang lalu
jhakanaka420 said:
agree with the sebelumnya answers.i just want to add that James FOUGHT to save his family.Lily didn't take up arms against Voldemort.she pleaded him to spare her child and came between the two even after telah diberi the choice to save herself.

when harry goes to the forbidden forest himself,he doesn't touch his wand to protect himself.that's how his sacrifice saves others as well.
 select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
James didn't fight either - he couldn't, he'd left his wand in the living room. When he shouts that he'll hold Voldemort off, what he actually means is that the time Voldemort takes to kill him might hopefully give Lily the chance to Apparate out with Harry. But she didn't have her wand either.
Flickerflame posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!