My teacher won't let my class read Harry Potter because in her eyes it's "Murderous and Evil". Your thoughts?

Your teacher is entitled to her opinion - whatever that may be, however anda may think of it. That's why I won't say anything bad about her.

If she banned it from the classroom, well, so be it. She's entitled to do so. But what prevents anda from Membaca it once at utama atau outside the classroom/the school ? (in case it may have been banned from the school grounds too). Your teacher has no jurisdiction over what happens in your utama atau even outside the school grounds.

I say this as a teacher myself.

That's an excellent opportunity for anda to tunjuk a bit of independence ! anda read it, anda like it, end of the story. Do anda really need other people to make your own opinion about anything, be they your teacher atau even ourselves here ? Just read the books/watch the Filem if anda want to. Don't be afraid...

tell her to read it.

That's stupid last tahun I had a teacher who loved Harry Potter.It was her kegemaran book to read to the class

Maybe anda should ask her if she's ever read them. Because one of the things I've noticed about people who say that Harry Potter is satanic and evil is that they've never even bothered to read the books. They just see the cover and the plot summary and jump to the conclusion that it must promote witchcraft.

neglect ur teacher's comment!!!
itz really not like tht at all!!!!!

She won't let y'all read it in class atau at home, too?

If it's in class, then it does sort of make sense because of the religious extremists who might be upset that their child is Membaca it. But the "murderous and evil" part? Most good literature has a bit of death in it, so if she's trying to tunjuk y'all good writing, then finding something without death is going to be hard. And the whole series is about fighting against evil and embracing love, so I don't know how she got the "evil" tag. But, then again, she may be one of those religious nuts. (I'm not saying that everyone who's religious is a nut, just those who see Harry Potter on the surface and think that the readers are worshiping Satan.)

That's a bit of an exaggeration. Even if anda don't like HP I don't see how it fits either of these adjectives. :/

tunjuk this page to your teacher

Well, personally the buku have a great plot and moral, which I think teachers should encourage to read. buku wouldn't bE fun without a little mix of Fantasi and reality Which Harry potter DEFINITELY has.

Peppergirl, the world if filled with narrow-minded people. Narrow-mindedness = ignorance. It's wonderful when anda can bring enlightenment, but when they are people in power, such as a teacher atau boss, anda learn to roll with it, keeping your own convictions true. Remember, someday you'll be the boss.

What do anda mean "won't let the class read it"? Do anda mean she won't let anda bring the book into the classroom at all, atau she won't make it a class assignment to read?

There's a big difference between the two.

If she won't let anda bring the book into the classroom to read on your own, (as in, when anda have free-time), then I would go to the principal atau the school board.

If she just won't make it an assigned reading, then that makes sense. For starters (as VampiresRevenge pointed out), there's a lot of religious issues with the book. Her komen about it being "evil" just highlights that. Also, English teachers (if she is an English teacher) can't just randomly decide to read a book series half-way through the tahun that wasn't on the syllabus to read. Especially not if the book wasn't on the approved Membaca list.

To bad for her bring it in anyways. She can't tell anda what not to read she's not your mom. She should be estatic that anda even want to read!

Read it anyway.

She is sick. How can Harry Potter be evil??

HARRY POTTER RULES DAMMIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

She's murderous and evil. Harry Potter is about a war, and how it really affects people. If anda don't get kids ready for the trajedies of war, they will not be prepared. Death happens in life. Harry's parents were killed because they tried to save him. Now why is that wrong?

Sounds to me like this "teacher" needs an education.

If anda haven't read a book atau seen a movie, anda have absolutely no freaking business critiquing it. If she hasn't read the books, her opinion of the saga is irrelivent.

LOL my teachers dont like Harry Potter too.they say if anda read it anda wont come back alive,last tahun my maths (we finished the book earley) teacher wouldnt let me do that,but i thout about the rules its not ilegle in your school,i told the teacher about it,she berkata anda can bring it,but keep it away from me would you

my teacher is PERFECTLY FINE with the whole class Membaca harry potter. he even let me write: for journal writing, "My Time At Hogwarts" instead of "My holidays" and i get to read them to the whole class and they liked it :D

Unless anda can prove that there is something truly bad (like, innapropriate content, language, etc.) teachers shouldn't be allowed to ban a book. But if she doesn't let anda guys read it, just read it somewhere else, I guess.