They both are, but I see more Gold fans.

Why the Fan Favorite Villain of course. ;)
However the Mr. Gold fans are more active.

I think the Regina fans are the most active! lol!

I'd say it's about even probably, depending where you go one will have the edge over the other a bit. They're both hugely popular either way.

Mr. Gold is definitely winning the popularity contest!! ^_^

I think only a "few" Regina fans are active. ;)
Both are great but Evil Queenie has the Fan Favorite Award to showcase. ^_^

I don't understand how Regina got fan favorite? Mr Gold is way more popular with the fans :)

I wish Mr. Gold's fans were more active :'( I don't see them posting pictures, fanarts, commenting and debating as much as Regina's fans. She seems to have few, but very active fans...

On tumblr.com I'd defiantly say Gina's more poular. It just depends on which website you go to.

I have an account on tumblr and I can definitely say that on this site Regina's not more popular!

of all the fan categories (charmers, evil regals, dearies), the dearie category is the most highly populated.
i'm definitely a die hard for rumple/ gold though so maybe my opinion is biased.
on my tumblr dashboard, rumple is way more popular than gina, but i love them both :)

He's keeping us on our toes, wondering where his ultimate loyalty will lie, and he's got this aura of a good side that's fighting to get out.

Eh, I always see Gina more on my dash...

^maybe because you're following the blogs dedicated to her! ^_^

oh my god everybody just LOVES him

Definitely. He's got a pretty big following of fangirls (including myself).
I love them both though. The two best characters on the show! Every scene between these two is epic :)

Before starting to watch the show, I remember I kept seeing sooooo many Gold related posts and just thinking ''Who is this guy and why is he everywhere???''