Disney Princess Club
sertai
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
posted by deedragongirl
 Who do anda choose? Live-action reboot atau Animated???
Who do you choose? Live-action reboot or Animated???
So, since Disney has release 2 live-action reboots of their Disney classic animated feature. Here is what I think about which movie is better, as well as their animated counterparts.

Cinderella (1950 & 2015)

I would definitely go for the live-action version, as mentioned in my sebelumnya articles. Ella has lebih personality compare to her animated counterpart, and of course, less screen-time for the mice.
However, no Bruno the dog! Also, no songs in it. I wish it was, but on the other hand, the producers and Kenneth Brannagh didn't want the movie to be to close to its original 1950 animated version.
I was also very neutral that the 2 stepsisters in the reboot were tone done for comic relief, whereas in their animated version. They're like torture machines! Especially the dress-ripping scene.
Lady Tremaine was very faithful to her namesake version, and I Cinta it! Although there were lebih evilness in the 2015 version.
My conclusion is that it is even better than the original 1950 version, and I'm happy that this is the first time that a Disney live-action reboot was faithful to its original animated features, despite some changes to it. So, I give credits to Kenneth Branagh and the cast of the movie.

Maleficent & Sleeping Beauty (2014 vs 1959)

Before watching the 2014 movie, I initially thought that it was the origins of Maleficent's backstory prior to the events of 1959 animated feature. However, as the movie processes, they make King Stefan into a psychopath willing to kill the fairy. In other words, their roles are reverse.
On the other hand, Aurora's role is expand and we get to see her personality as well as her interaction with other characters more.
In the original 1959 version, we get to know Maleficent as pure evil and the Mistress of All Evil! Aurora's role was minor but we get to know her as a very spunky and happy-go-lucky character. Although I felt bad for her when she realises that she's a princess and will never see this handsome stranger ever again, unbeknownst to her, it's Prince Philip!
Speaking of Prince Philip, I was disappointed about the 2014 version of him. He was not as useful and proactive as his namesake animated counterpart! He was a Prince Caspian wannabe, in fact it could be his younger brother atau cousin.
Lastly, I heard that Maleficent was faithful towards the original Grimm Brothers' version sejak claiming that it has 1 rape scene, in particularly the scene where Maleficent's wing was chop off sejak a teenage King Stefan.

Conclusion

For me, it is the 2015 version of Cinderella and the 1959 version of Sleeping Beauty. These 2 Filem are always be my no.1 Disney Filem and it will teaches young girls with moral support.
 Team Maleficent atau Team Cinderella?? Choose your pick!
Team Maleficent or Team Cinderella?? Choose your pick!
 I got a crash on you!
I got a crash on you!
 Caspian's twin brother, atau is it?
Caspian's twin brother, or is it?
added by jessowey
Source: disneywallpapers.info
added by flowerdrop
added by kristenfan10109
added by CRaZy_rawR
added by purplevampire
added by LibelluleBleu
Source: Disneycentralplaza
added by PrincessFairy
Source: http://steelboneddiva.tumblr.com/post/69346839856/christmas-2013-elsa
added by mhs1025
Source: Disney screencaps
added by tiffany88
added by tiffany88
added by mhs1025
Source: Disney screencaps
added by purplevampire
added by sweetie-94
added by sweetie-94
added by Ribon95
Source: Ribon95
added by jessowey
Source: 1Zoom.com
added by MJ_Fan_4Life007