Personally, I think they are both great actresses but people don't give them a chance b/c they started off in kid/teen movies. I think Lindsay is especially underrated b/c of what is going on in her personal life right now - it's really a shame. I look forward to seeing her back on the big screen delivering a knockout performance :)

Everything about Hilary is so average (talent, looks, personality, movies..)

Hilary is amazing. One of the very few (if only) Disney stars that has managed to keep her life together. I think she's a great actress. I have heaps of respect for her.

better actress-but I prefer Hilary as a person-BY FAR.

I much prefer Hilary as a person, but Lindsay is definitely a much better actress. People are biased against Lindsay's talents because of her personal life - I think she was good before it all went wrong, it's a shame really. :/

such a waste of talent.

If she wasn't so messed up right now she would have won an Oscar. I still love Linsey and I hope she comes back someday. I used to like Hilary but she annoys me now.