Do anda think the release of Stephenie Meyer's Midnight Sun is necessary? Since it's only the repetition of Twilight but only in Edward's POV...

It's not really necessary. I mean, if SM didn't announce she was Penulisan the story in his perspective, I wouldn't have thought about it atau wanted it. But it is interesting to read from his point of view. Not everyone, especially those who've only seen the movies, gets his character. If anda base Edward's character on the movie and the book Twilight, anda see him as obsessive and overprotective. Although that's true, Midnight Sun, anda see why he does the things he does and how he struggles. SM explains in Midnight Sun what Edward deals with. How much control it took him to resist Bella, how he ended up in her bedroom, how he dealt with not being able to read her mind, and so on. i think it would be beneficial to alot of people who want to know lebih about his character. That's one of the main reasons why SM chose to write Twilight from his POV. We know Bella's character pretty well since she's been the one narrating. Midnight Sun was so that people can understand Edward a little more.

I think she should have written it from his point of view in the first place. Bella is a difficult heroine (I use the term loosely) to follow to begin with and I think the parts later on that are from Jacob's point of view are really helpful in understanding his own screwed up actions. Maybe some of the controversy around Bella being such a crappy role model and Edward being so creepy could have been avoided if she'd written it that way to begin with. I think at this point it just feels like lebih of cash grab than for the Cinta of the characters and the damage has already been done when it comes to the ridiculousness of everyone in the story's actions.

saat verse same as the first...great. *sarcastic tone inserted there* I'm sorry, but now we go from hearing the story told from a weak little girl onto the POV of a masacistic, dominaring, stalking, keldai who sparkles...Yeah, that just...not cool atau necessary. If she wants to make a good book, try publishing buku from the Volturi's point of veiw. They were all terrific characters that I'd Cinta to learn lebih about. Why let good characters like these guys go to waste?

Im not much for burning buku but...well I think something along those lines needs to happen fast before girls get too involved.

But of course it is! She needs to make lebih money, so she will continue milking the series for as long as the market allows her to.

I read what she'd written of Midnight Sun back in the hari and I thought it was great Membaca from Edwards point-of-view (but then again I thought he was lik SUCH a babe!1!). Perplexed is right she probably should have written the whole series like that in the first place. Her Penulisan doesn't really explain much of Edwards actions properly (hence we think he's the only psycho stalker in history who sparkles to attract victims) and it makes a lot lebih sense when he's the main character. We'd also probably be a lot lebih fond of Bella as well. But the buku already been written, the Filem already been made. We don't need the same book.

i think its necesary. i would Cinta to read it all from edward's POV. but i hope somewhere in the book it goes on after breaking dawn.

No, because it's just a way for her to make it last longer.

I can't stand the idea of another Twi-book.Please, for literature's sake x"(

No But, It Will Be Interesting
The Creepy Thing Is The A Long Time lalu When Like New Moon Came Out I berkata If She Were To Make A 5th Book It Would Be Midnight Sun...O.o

Its not necessary at all we pretty much know the whole story Vampires vs Serigala Jadian why make anoter book

No, not really its just the story of twilight but from a different characters perspective. To be honest i think its bieng written due to the amount of money she'll make out of Penulisan it. If it was Carlisles point of view then probably, because i like Membaca parts about his past. But edward? Not really my favourite character. Is she going to do one for the rest of the buku all edwards perspective and then do one thats all jacobs perspective? She could make a whole load of money out of that unfortunately :S