For me the screencaps are better

I don't mind any really... aslong as all the princesses are included.
I'd also prefer it if all the princesses are wearing their most iconic outfits so...
Ariel in either mermiad attire or her pink gown.
Jasmine probably in her blue outfit
Mulan maybe in her pink dress
Tiana in her green transformation dress
Rapunzel in her purple dress worn throughout her film
:D

I think the screencaps portray them better but we would all have problems deciding on which screencap to use... So I really don't care too much about whether we use screencaps/merchandose.

I think all of the princesses (specially Snow White) look prettier in the merchandise pictures...

Definitely screencaps.
On screencaps Disney Princesses look way better than in the merchandise pictures, more classical and prettier.

I think the screen caps look better and describe the princesses better.

We'd never all be able to agree on screencaps to use- beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and I know that I really dislike some users' favorite screencaps. All we have to do is use alafasztanzio-edited pictures, so that the girls look better.

We shouldn't really restrict entries in the contest to screencap or lineup- what if someone has a really nice lineup one, but he/she can't enter it (or vice-versa)?

I know they don't look realistic in the merchandise pictures, but I agree with firegirl, it would be the easier to do.

I vote for screencaps. They look SO much better that way.

Hmm, I don't really know. The merch pics have really nice crisp look to them. I also like how we have two different things going on with the banner and the icon, one showing the movie/real side of the princesses, then one showing them from a franchise standpoint.

I like the screencaps though because they show the princesses as they really are, and it shows more of their personality.

My only real conditions that I want in a banner is that;
1. It accurately shows all 10 princesses (With the exception of Rapunzel possibly being in 2-D with in a merch banner)
2. All the princesses are in their most iconic outfits

Because I saw how Rapunzel looks and she looks kinda weird looking so do Jasmine, Belle, and Pocahontas

@firegirl1515: Totally agree. If I run it, I'm not going to restrict it as at the first time.
I made this pick to see what fans think of it. And I think it'd be better if in the forum post we'll mention it.
For example: fans prefer merchandise pictures, so the main focus will be on such pictures, but not only them. Sure.
I for one don't mind any. :)

Although I love them in screencaps, it doesn't seem official. So, i'm going with the merchandise one.

I really like the merchandise one we have but I also like the idea of using screencaps. I don't really care what kind we have, as long as it's good and includes all the princesses.

Because they look so much prettier, also it's easier for me.

I DON'T like how they look in merchandise (with the exception of Snow White and maybe Ariel) but I agree 100% with firegirl1515.

I agree with hindaa and firegirl1515 :)