jawab soalan ini

Siri-siri Twilight Soalan

ok i still get confused at this, but does Bella Cinta Jacob. because if she does then she doesn't really Cinta Edward with all her hati, tengah-tengah does she?

 petramc posted hampir setahun yang lalu
next question »

Siri-siri Twilight Jawapan

Katherine-P said:
It´s unsure. I think after Edward leaves and Bella thought he would never come back she had in anytime began to thought about that she had to face the future. She fell in Cinta with Jacob but when Edward cames back she was helpless. She didn´t fell in Cinta with Jacob when she thought there was a chance that she´ll get Edward back. I see it in that way: She loved Edward with her whole heart. He leaves. Then she fell in Cinta when she thought she could never see Edward again. He came back. Her feelings struggled and she Lost her whole hati, tengah-tengah again on Edward. Her feelings for Jacob were weaker. Because her hati, tengah-tengah always belonged to Ed :)
select as best answer
 It´s unsure. I think after Edward leaves and Bella thought he would never come back she had in anytime began to thought about that she had to face the future. She fell in Cinta with Jacob but when Edward cames back she was helpless. She didn´t fell in Cinta with Jacob when she thought there was a chance that she´ll get Edward back. I see it in that way: She loved Edward with her whole heart. He leaves. Then she fell in Cinta when she thought she could never see Edward again. He came back. Her feelings struggled and she Lost her whole hati, tengah-tengah again on Edward. Her feelings for Jacob were weaker. Because her hati, tengah-tengah always belonged to Ed :)
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
edwardrobertcul said:
ok, it's really confusing!! in fact, i believe she loves jacob, but her big, true Cinta is obviously EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!
select as best answer
 ok, it's really confusing!! in fact, i believe she loves jacob, but her big, true Cinta is obviously EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
Angrykittykj said:
I fully believe that she never really loved Jacob. He spent all of Eclipse emotionally blackmailing her into believing that she did, but as she says in New Moon "I wish Jacob was my brother so I could have a claim on him." He was her best friend though, that much is true. But what Bella and Jacob didn't realize is that there were other forces drawing them together, namely Renesmee. As soon as she is born all of their feelings toward each other are gone. It's like she was always a part of Bella and Jacob was in Cinta with that part of her.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
so basically she doesn't Cinta Jacob in that sense?
petramc posted hampir setahun yang lalu
*
That's exactly what I believe. I could be wrong though, I'm just a peminat and I'm not inside Stephenie Meyer's head. That is just what it seemed like to me.
Angrykittykj posted hampir setahun yang lalu
cassie-1-2-3 said:
I believe she loved Jacob, but not all Cinta is the same.

She had a familial Cinta for Jacob. He was like a part of her family. She didn't have desires to touch him and Ciuman him like she did Edward. She ony wanted him to be present in her life.

She had a romantic Cinta for Edward.

Loving your family doesn't mean anda Cinta your romantic interest any less.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
*
thanxs guys that makes lebih sense now.
petramc posted hampir setahun yang lalu
katiecain said:
What she says in Eclipse:

'Jacob was right. He’d been right all along. He was lebih than just my friend. That’s why it was so impossible to tell him goodbye — because I was in Cinta with him. Too.'

Of course it's subjective but yes, Bella has berkata she was in Cinta with him. And not as in a brotherly Cinta as she kissed him.
select as best answer
posted hampir setahun yang lalu 
next question »