Ooh so many posts, so many intriguing ideas to ponder...ahhh my brain!
Alright, well first I want to address the issue of Cuddy and how some people are a little pissed that she reacted the way that she did. I don't have any quotes at the moment, but at least a few of you expressed the belief that since Cuddy told House that she did not want to change him, the fact that she is hurt by his lying is tantamount to her going back on her word.
The thing is, though, (and I see that a couple of you agree with me on this) is that it's not always so easy to follow through on your promises. In that moment in "Now What", Cuddy truly believed that she didn't want House to change. When she said it, she meant it. But in that moment, House was hurt. At that specific point and time, he wasn't being mean to her, he wasn't doing anything behind her back (at least to her knowledge), and saying that she didn't want him to change was easy. I'm not saying that it is not true. But when Cuddy is forced to confront House's problems and the "horrible things" that he inevitably does, you can't expect her not to be hurt.
Cuddy also has had good reason to believe that House HAS changed, if only in a small way. Up until now, he has been uncharacteristically careful at work, trying to avoid stepping on her shoes. There have been some minor problems, but up until this episode House has kept his word that he will be "brutally honest" with Cuddy. Perhaps, in those four episodes' worth of time, Cuddy began to believe that they had already settled into the comfortable rhythm, the balance between their professional and personal lives, that would last for the duration of their relationship. However, in "Office Politics", she now has to face the facts: the truth is, House had not been presented with this kind of decision in those four previous episodes. Cuddy had been lulled into a sense of security, and when she suddenly realizes that she was wrong, that House was indeed still capable of doing "horrible things" to her, of course she was surprised, hurt, and disappointed. You can't blame her for that.
To sum up the previous little rant above, I don't believe that Cuddy is contradicting what she said in "Now What". I don't think that Cuddy ever EXPECTED him to change. But, House did change--this change could be temporary, it could be so small that it is barely noticeable, but it undeniably happened. And so, Cuddy saw this change and started BELIEVING that House had changed, even though she had never expected him to. So, his decision to lie to her in this episode was a harsh jolt back to reality for her.
This ties in with what @mav said, a few posts above. I think that on top of her disappointment that she was wrong and that House lied to her, Cuddy is also very much disappointed in herself for letting herself believe that House might have changed. She might even be recalling her words from "Now What" and scolding herself for ever thinking that House had been wrong when he had said that he would inevitably do "horrible things" to her. Whatever her other emotions are, I am sure that Cuddy is a little angry at herself.
So, all in all, it's just very complicated. Then again, Huddy was bound to be full of complications. I believe that House made the right decision, but I also believe that Cuddy is right to be disappointed in him. Then again, I think that she shouldn't have let herself believe that House changed, even if she had not expected him to. Of course, overarching all these thoughts, I WANT HUDDY TO LAST FOREVER.
Yes, it's all very complicated. I just know that Cuddy should not be blamed for her emotions. No one is perfect, and no one can always keep to their word. When Cuddy told House that she didn't want him to change, yes it sounded nice, and yes she meant it, but human beings are all too easily caught up in fantasies of their own making. Although Cuddy did not expect House to change, a small part of it pounced on the opportunity to believe that he did. But this is a human weakness: you can't blame her for that.
Alright, well first I want to address the issue of Cuddy and how some people are a little pissed that she reacted the way that she did. I don't have any quotes at the moment, but at least a few of you expressed the belief that since Cuddy told House that she did not want to change him, the fact that she is hurt by his lying is tantamount to her going back on her word.
The thing is, though, (and I see that a couple of you agree with me on this) is that it's not always so easy to follow through on your promises. In that moment in "Now What", Cuddy truly believed that she didn't want House to change. When she said it, she meant it. But in that moment, House was hurt. At that specific point and time, he wasn't being mean to her, he wasn't doing anything behind her back (at least to her knowledge), and saying that she didn't want him to change was easy. I'm not saying that it is not true. But when Cuddy is forced to confront House's problems and the "horrible things" that he inevitably does, you can't expect her not to be hurt.
Cuddy also has had good reason to believe that House HAS changed, if only in a small way. Up until now, he has been uncharacteristically careful at work, trying to avoid stepping on her shoes. There have been some minor problems, but up until this episode House has kept his word that he will be "brutally honest" with Cuddy. Perhaps, in those four episodes' worth of time, Cuddy began to believe that they had already settled into the comfortable rhythm, the balance between their professional and personal lives, that would last for the duration of their relationship. However, in "Office Politics", she now has to face the facts: the truth is, House had not been presented with this kind of decision in those four previous episodes. Cuddy had been lulled into a sense of security, and when she suddenly realizes that she was wrong, that House was indeed still capable of doing "horrible things" to her, of course she was surprised, hurt, and disappointed. You can't blame her for that.
To sum up the previous little rant above, I don't believe that Cuddy is contradicting what she said in "Now What". I don't think that Cuddy ever EXPECTED him to change. But, House did change--this change could be temporary, it could be so small that it is barely noticeable, but it undeniably happened. And so, Cuddy saw this change and started BELIEVING that House had changed, even though she had never expected him to. So, his decision to lie to her in this episode was a harsh jolt back to reality for her.
This ties in with what @mav said, a few posts above. I think that on top of her disappointment that she was wrong and that House lied to her, Cuddy is also very much disappointed in herself for letting herself believe that House might have changed. She might even be recalling her words from "Now What" and scolding herself for ever thinking that House had been wrong when he had said that he would inevitably do "horrible things" to her. Whatever her other emotions are, I am sure that Cuddy is a little angry at herself.
So, all in all, it's just very complicated. Then again, Huddy was bound to be full of complications. I believe that House made the right decision, but I also believe that Cuddy is right to be disappointed in him. Then again, I think that she shouldn't have let herself believe that House changed, even if she had not expected him to. Of course, overarching all these thoughts, I WANT HUDDY TO LAST FOREVER.
Yes, it's all very complicated. I just know that Cuddy should not be blamed for her emotions. No one is perfect, and no one can always keep to their word. When Cuddy told House that she didn't want him to change, yes it sounded nice, and yes she meant it, but human beings are all too easily caught up in fantasies of their own making. Although Cuddy did not expect House to change, a small part of it pounced on the opportunity to believe that he did. But this is a human weakness: you can't blame her for that.